The American Defence Of The Christian Golden Rule.
Argument the First.
THe more a Man becomes conformable to the Attributes of God, the more just and holy he is, and the more beloved of God, and consequently a more perfect Christian.
First, then, God hath given to man a FreeWill, so that he is Master of his own Choice (whether it be good or evil) and will in no way force and compel the Will of man; yea, not unto that part which is good, far less unto evil, notwithstanding his Attribute of Omnipotence. And seeing then, it is thus with God and his Creatures, we ought also to do so by our fellow mortals, and therefore we ought not to force and compel our fellow creatures, the Negroes, Nay, not although we judge it for them a better way of living; For when we force their will, this is a manifest Robbery of that noble Gift their bountiful Creator hath given them, and is a right down Contradiction to the aforesaid Attributes of God, and consequently an Anti-Christian Practice And so, those that oppose God and his Attributes, they may expect [Page 2] to incur his Displeasure; So they may find a pregnant Instance in Pharaoh and his Egyptian Task-Masters.
2 dly. This Practice contradicts Christs command, who commanded us, To do to all men as we would they should do to us, or as we would be done by. Now the buying and selling of the Bodies and Souls of Men, was and is the Merchandize of the Babylonish Merchants spoken of in the Revelations. Now the Tyranizing over and making Slaves of our Fellow Creatures, the Negroes, every one knows, or may know, this is not the way they would be done unto.
Now, I have shown you, first, That this Practice opposes God and his Attributes, and 2 dly, That it opposes Christ and his Command; And what is this in Effect but to bid Defyance, and to live in Opposition to Christ and his Gospel? and if so, it is a high Degree of an Antichristian Life and Practice.
And now, my beloved Friends, who are concerned in this Practice, as you love the Welfare of your immortal Souls, I intreat you (for it is for your sakes I labour) not lightly to look over these considerations, if ye think to receive a Reward for the Deeds done in the Body; For how will ye answer when ye are brought before Gods Tribunal, and there appear naked and bear before the Son of Man, if ye have lived and dyed in Opposition to his everlasting Gospel, for the confirmation of which, for our Sakes, cost him his precious Life, and now for a little worldly Interest, got in Opposition to Christ and [...] Gospel, by the Bondage and Inslaving of Negroes; the very Reading of which is enough to make [Page 3] all Hearts concerned to tremble. The very thoughts of this makes me declare, for all the Riches and Honours of this world, I would not be found in this Antichristian Life and Practice.
3 ly, I have shewed before, That GOD, who is no respecter of persons, hath given to all men a Freedom of their Wills, to pitch upon their own choice, for both Soul and Body, which are the only parts, next unto the Life, the free donation of our heavenly Father, in this terrestrial world; But it would seem by the Negro-Masters Practice and Arguments, that God did miss the matter, by his Wisdom, when he gave the Negros (his Creatures) the Freedom of their Wills; but our Negro-Masters have found out, by their Inginuity, how to mend this (seeming) Defect, in two respects, to wit, that is to rob them of their Freedom, and make them bond-Slaves and their Posterity forever. And in the next place, they can highly inrich themselves by the Bargain; by the unparallelled and never enough lamented Bondage and Slavery of those poor Creatures and handy work of God, And can afford to keep themselves with white hands, except at some Times they chance to be be sparkled with the Blood of those poor Slaves, when they fall to beating them with their twisted Hides and Horse-whips, and other Instruments of Cruelty, too barbarous here to relate, all done in the name of their deservings and correction. And furthermore, they can afford (by their beloved Diana, their Slaves) to go with fine powdered Perriwigs, and great bunched [Page 4] Coats; and likewise keep their Wives idle ( Jezebel [...] like) to paint their Faces, and Puff, and powder their Hair, and to bring up their Sons and Daughters in Idleness and Wantonness, and in all manner of Pride and Prodigality, in deek [...]ng and adorning their Carkasses with pufft and powdered Hair, with Ruffles and T [...]p-knots, Ribbands and Lace, and gay Cloathing, and what not; All, and much more, the miserable Effects produced by the Slavery of Negroes; and their Slaves in the [...]lest Raggs, much ado to cover their nakedness, and many of them not a Shirt upon their Backs, and some of them not a Shoe upon their Foot in cold Frosts and Snow in the Winter Time, that many of them have their Feet and other members frozen off, by reason of their Cruel Usage; and some of them must lie by the Fire among the Ashes, or be driven out to lie in Huts out of Doors among the worst of their Dogs, for some of the finest of their Dogs they permit to lie in the bed with themselves.
And they accomodate their Slaves which such Names as these, T [...]by, Mando, Ming [...], Jack, Hect [...]r and Hagar, and such like Names they give to their Dogs and Horses.
And when their Masters see fit they will hang them up by their Thumbs, and then command another Negro to beat him so long, as his Master sees fit; this he must not refuse to do, if it were his own Father, nay, further, they will force them to be very Hang-men; And notwithstanding of all this, some of them must go with a hungry Belly, and that which they do get to eat (ye need not [Page 5] doubt but it) is the worst the House affords.
Now all that fear God cannot but know that those men who use such Cruelty are not only [...] of the Fear of God, but are even destitute of humane Civility, and Pity and Mercy; Therefore their Example can be no more a Rule for keeping Slaves than it is for using such inhumane Cruelty, which all sober Men abhor; For it cannot be expected that men of such Cruelty have much regard to the lawfulness of what they do, and it is great Pity that men who are naturally more moderate and merciful should be led to the Practice of an unlawful thing by the Example of the vilest of men.
But to return to the Servants of such cruel Masters; By this Description all may see, that they are put under an unavoidable Necessity of [...]inning to maintain self-Preservation, an Instinct of Nature belonging to all the Creatures of God; So self-preservation puts them to steal, rob, and lye, and many other sinfull Actions; nay, some of them when they see themselves surrounded and trappaned with all the Miscries aforesaid, and many more, then they go into Dispair, and miserably [...] themselves, and som [...] their Masters, to get rid of their Tortures and miserable Slavish Life There was one of them ( I think) within less then two years ago, shot himself whi [...]h a Gun, near his Masters House, within a few miles off the place where I write this lamentable story.
Now for those heinous Sins, as Lying, stealing, Robbing, and Self-Murder; they cannot [Page 6] escape Punishment, by the Justice of God. Now as I have said before, they being put under such necessity of sinning, and they themselves being but Infidels, I desire the Negro-Masters to inform me, who must answer for all these abominable Sins?
And now, Reader, I have given thee a small View of the Usage and Treatment of these poor miserable Slaves; for if I would enlarge upon their Usage, I need write nothing else to swell up a Book to I know not what bigness; The parting of Man and Wi [...]e being such a heinous sin committed by the Negro-Masters, I cannot pass by; The parting the Husband from the Wife, and the Wife from the Husband, and their Children from them both, to make up their Masters Gains, they force them thus to break the seventh Command, and commit Adultery with other strangers, or other mens Wives or Husbands. These and the like Usages, is enough to make them believe, there is no God at all, and harden them in Idolatrous Worship, and make them blaspheme against the holy God, that he takes not immediate Vengeance on such notorious Offenders. And here are the first three Commands broken, occasioned by their Masters. And the breaking the fourth is evident to all; for some, for want of Food and other necessaries, for all their hard weeks Labour to inrich their Master, for to maintain Self-preservation, puts them to work on the First Day of the Week, to supply their pure Necessities, and so break that which their Masters call the Christian [Page 7] Sabbath. And so, here is all the Commands of the first Table broken by them, occasioned by the Cruelty of their Masters. And their Children being sold from their Parents, they unavoidably cannot honour them; and here is the breach of the fifth. And to get rid of their miserable Tortures, many kill themselves and others; and here is the breach of the Sixth. The parting of Man and Wife makes them commit Adultery with others; and here is the breach of the Seventh. To maintain Self-preservation, they unavoidably must steal; and here is the breach of the Eight. Then they run away to avoid their Tortures, and when they are catcht their Master will ask them, Do you not deserve to be hung up and Beat? and here they must bear False witness against themselves (which is worse than against their Neighbours) and say, yes, I do, we serve to be hung up and Beat; and here is the breach of the ninth. And when they are in great necessity of Food and Rayment, and have it not of their own, they unavoidably must covet it of their Neighbours, and here is the breach of the Tenth.
Now Reader, here are all the Ten Commands of God (occasioned by their Masters) broken by them. This is such a Charge, that I doubt it will be too hot or too heavy for the Negro-Masters to answer.
And now that those Christians who in their Baptism did engage to keep all gods holy commands, should not keep them, but break them themselves and for their own Gains, do lay all manner of unavoidable Necessities upon their Slavs [Page 8] to break them also; This is a poor encouragement for Godfathers indeed.
I may truly say, as Nestori [...]s did, who [...] Arch-Bishop of Constantinople, and was banished from them by the prevailing Party in his Time, to the outermost part of the Roman Empire among the Barbarians, because he said and taught. That Mary ought not to be called the Mother of God, but the Mother of Christ, and that it could not go down with him to say, that God was a year old, or a Month, or a Day old, &c. As we may read in that great Book called Eusebius. And when he found great Kindness from those Barbarians he wrote a learned and eloquent better to those Christians that banished him, to this Effect, that For his Banishment he could undergo it patiently, but his Fear and Lamentation was, that their Actions should go unto the Heathen, that thereby they should be imboldened in Heathenism, and give them Advantage to blaspheme against Christ and the Christian Religion; And so advised them not to be a stop and a Hinderance to that glorious Gospel that had cost so many Lives for the spreading and advancing of it.
Now, I can truly say, that this is my concern as it was the concern of Nestori [...], that ever the Actions of our American Negro-Masters should go unto the Turks and other Heathen Nations, to harden them in Mah [...]metant'm and other Heathenism, and to imbolden them to blaspheme against Christ and his Gospel, and the purest Christianity.
I wish this may come to be the concern of [Page 9] our Negro-Masters, That they be not hinder [...], but Advancers of the glorious Gospel, and then I am sure they will be loath to do to any other Man what they would not be done by themselves.
Now, it is not unpossible but that an American Negro Master and a Turk should meet and discourse this Point betwixt them, And the Turk should say, ‘I am well pleased, Brother that you and we agree so well in this Point, viz. in making Slaves of them we can have the Mastery over; And I doubt not but many of us have been at a stand whether it may not be a sin to use our fellow Creatures so cruelly: but now I think it is Time to give over such Doubts, when we see it so mightily practised by the Christians, I mean the American Christians; I make this Distinction, because it is not practised in Europe.’
And now, Brother, I would argue a little plainer with you, How comes it to pass, that you find Fault with us for making Slaves of Men, when you your selves do the same? How can that be an evil and a sin in us, which is a Christian Practice among your selves? And I hear, that when any of your Slaves turns Christian, and is baptized and receives the Christian Faith, you keep them in perpetual Slavery for all, and so they have no encouragment to turn Christian upon that score, which shews to me, that you have but a small Esteem for your Religion, or at least are very lukewarm for Proselytes.
[Page 10] This is worse then Turks; for when any of our Slaves turn, and embraces the Mah [...]metan Faith, they are no longer Slaves, but presently set free, and many Times preferred to Places of Trust and Dignity, such zeal have we for Proselytes, and our Religion.
And how comes it that you differ among your selves in this Practice? for there are some zealous men among you, that both dispute and write against you, and they declare it to be an Antichristian Practice; And the Christians in Europe do not practice it. And I have heard that the Gospel was, Glory to God in [...] Highest, and Peace and Good Will [...]o all Men upon Earth, and that ye should do to all men as ye would they should do to you. And if this be the Gospel of the blessed Messiah, I will tell you plainly, I took upon you to be apostatized in this Point, and I would advise you either to embrace the rest of our Mahometan Practices (and then we would receive you) or otherwise to walk more closely to the Rules and Practice of Christianity; and not to content your selves with a Name, and to be a perpetual Scandal to the rest of Christians.
So far Mahometan.
ANd now, Christians of after Ages to come, Its not unlikely, but ye may meet with the Force and Assaults of Negro-Masters, as we in this Age have done, (And so, Christian, defend thy self as we have done before thee) And so to [Page 11] cloak their Impiety, and to make the best S [...]ew of Pretences they can, they may thus begin.
Negr [...] Master. Had not Gods People (in all Ages) bond Slaves, bought with their Money?
Christians Answer. So had they their many Wives and Concubines, and I see no more Reason to plead for Slaves then to plead for many Wives and Concubines.
Negro Master. It is true, we have as good Grounds for the one as for the other, and I will freely acknowledge that if the many Wives and Concubines would bring in such Advantage to us as our Negro-Slaves do, I doubt not but we should plead as st [...]fly for the one as for the other; But the many Wives and Concubines not being advantagous, we in Discretion drop that part of our Argument, and keep close to that which brings us Gains? So I need not enlarge to trouble my self to cite every chapter and Verse, for I take it for a Maxim, That all the Old Testament, where it treats upon that subject, is upon our side; and I have heard some of us alledge out of the New Testament, that Ph [...]lem [...] was a Slave, but since I have read Pools Annotations on the Place, I will not be so unmanly as to assert it as a Proof; I think I have Proof enough, that have the Old Testament, although I meddle not with the New.
And now I think I have proved by Scripture, that keeping of Slaves was practised of Old; And now I intend to shew that it is according to the Christianity of our Times, First by the consent [Page 12] and agrement of all the several Sects of Christians.
I begin then with the famous Bishops of England (who are not ignorant of our Negro- Practice) who by their Christian care do send their Missionaries hither to America, to teach the Inhabitants here the Principles and Practices of Christianity; And it is evident those Missionaries do make their Gains by Negro Slaves, and have their Houses crawling black with them, by which they set an Example to others to follow their s [...]eps; And not a word of Sin in all this. And I never heard that a Bishop ever wrote a word against it; by which I think it is evident that the making Slaves of Negroes is according to Church-Christianity.
And Secondly, I can shew by that famous and zealous Sect of Presbyterians, who have been diligent followers of the Principles and Practices of the Reformation, witness the Rejecting the [...] Mass-Book, and many other Roman Superstitions, so kind kindly entertained (as they think) by some of their Protestant Brethren; and a People very zealous in their Lives and Church Discipline; and yet both Preachers and People do joyntly agree with the Church in making Slaves of Negroes.
Thirdly, I can shew by that pious Sect of Anabaptists, Witness some of them their Modesty in Apparel, and their Dexterity in the Point of Water-Baptism, in telling the rest of Christians in Print, that they do cheat the World in the Point of Infant Baptism; but they very [Page 13] Lovingly embrace this Practice in making Slaves of Negroes.
Now if the Church, and Presbyterians, and Baptists did but agree so lovingly in other Points as they do in making Slaves of Negroes, I think they might be stiled One Community.
Now, if those several Sects of Christians and their unanimous Agreement in this Practice of making Slaves of Negroes, as I have already shewed, does not amount to a Proof, I know not what will,
Christians Answer, I do confess this is a Proof, that some of all those several Sects do Practise this Point of Impiety, which I would readily have confessed without a word of Proof, except what mine Eyes have seen; For all these Sects of People both by Principle and Practice do Fight, and Kill, and take away the Lives of many Thousands in Battles, for their inriching of themselves, and for their own Advantages, and therefore it is no Wonder that all those Sects agree so well in making Slaves of Negros, or others whom they can get the Mastery over (for their own Advantage.)
But as this is very forreign from Christianity, and out of the Peaceable Gospel of the blessed Messiah (for worrying, Tearing and Killing are the marks of Dogs, Wolves and Bears, which is the Practice of those aforesaid Sects of Christians, as they call themselves: but the Innocence of Lambs and Doves was and is the Characteristick of Christians) so I think this is sufficient to overset what was alledged for a Proof by the Practice [Page 14] of all those severol Sects of Christians for enslaving of their fellow Creatures the Negros For I thought the Gospel had not been Cruelty but had been Innocence, Love, Meekness, Patience, Long-Suffering, and plenteous in Forgiveness, and other Emblems of the Attributes of God, and that Christians were to give [...] Backs to the Smiter and their C [...]ecks to them that pluck off the Hair.
But I have a further Answer for you, and that is, I utterly deny that either Church-men or Presbyterians have generally agreed in making Slaves of Negros; For some of both have preached and some have printed against it here in North America; And some that have had Negroes their Conscience would not allow them to keep them for Slaves, but after some Time of Service they set them free.
Hence I infer, That making Slaves of men is an evil so abominable in the nature of it that men whose Principles are so large as to allow of Killing men, cannot allow of making Men Slaves, accounting it worse to Rob men o [...] their Liberty and Labour, who have done them no harm, then it is to kill them that rise up against them.
And hence I infer, that none would believe it lawfull, if they were not either blinded with the love of Gain, or with the plausible Pretences o [...] such as are.
Negro Master. Hold! I think I have another Proof, which, according to your own Argument I think will bind you. There is another numerous and famous sect of Christians, called [Page 15] Quakers, who by their Practice do show that they have all those aforesaid Marks which thou hast nominated, and therefore by consequence of your Argument the only true and real Christians, and yet there is no People more forward to make Slaves of Negros than they are; And now, if they be infallibly guided in all the other Principles and Practices of Christianity, one would think they could not be erroneous in this, viz. in making Slaves of Negros. And now, although all my other Arguments should fail, yet this last, one would think, should silence you.
Christians Answer. This, I confess, is the greatest Wonder, to see a People so conformable to the rest of the Principles and Practices of Christianity, induced by the Example of the looser Sorts of Christians, to embrace an enriching Sin, and sacrifice that command of Christ, to do to others what they would not be done by.
And yet I cannot see how they can be a Proof in this, above all other Christians, especially when it is thought by some of the honest hearted among them, that about the eleventh Year of the eighteenth Century the most of them Sacrificed their primitive Innocence, when they so lovingly agreed and joyned with the other Sects to pay the Souldiers their proportion of Wages to go in the Expedition against their Neighbours of Canada; And when they loose their lnnocence, I know not what they keep that is lovely among them.
But here I must make a Distinction; There [Page 16] was an honest hearted Remnant among them, that suffered joyfully the spoiling of their Goods in that Day, for the Answer of a good Conscience, and the Defence of the Antient Innocent Principle, in Denying the use of the Carnal Sword, Although it was not permitted to be recorded of suffering for the Truth, because the most numerous Party of them was guilty; But if the Reader, or any other, should come to question, whether they denyed the Use of the carnal Sword in any sense, for Proof of this, I refer such to their Wr [...]tings, Particularly to Robert Barclay's Apology, and to the Key wrote by William Penn, Where the Reader may see that they deny the Use of the Carnal Sword in any sense, yea, even in self-preservation, or so much as in Self-Defence, such Innocence was once maintained among them, which made Robert Barclay say, that it was their Innocent Lives and Practice that convinced him before he inspected into their Principles. The Innocent Lives of that People was the motive that convinced this pious learned man. He did not then see them lanching out Money to pay Souldiers to go and kill their fellow Creatures, nor did he see any of them making Slaves of Negroes; These and the like Practices were very remote from that Innocent and harmless People, called Quakers in Robert Barclays convincing day.
Negro Master. What have we to do with such far-fetch't Proofs? or what was in Barclay's Day? I love to keep at home, and the Practice of our American Christians; Are there not famous men [Page 17] here among the Quakers? and yet they are both Merchants and Masters of Negroes. But I think to argue this Point a little more closely; For before the eleventh year of the eighteenth Century (which is the year thou mentionedst) that they could not be a proof in this Point, more then other Christians, because they joyned with other Sects (in the Wars against Canada) they had Negro Slaves. But I will bring you to another Instance, viz. All the Time preceeding that fore-mentioned Year, particularly One thousand six hundred ninety two, when Andrew Hamilton was Governour of the Jersies, Did not all the Quakers refuse to pay the Souldiers to fight against the French at Albany? for the which Refual, great Havock was made of their Goods by Constables. Were not all the Quakers at Amboy strained, excepting one man that paid to maintain the Wars at Albany? And thou sayest, it was no wonder that this man afterward became a Negro-Master; For he was the first of that People that ever I heard of, that sacrificed that Innocent Principle (as thou callest it) and did pay the Rate that was raised to maintain the Albany War. Were they not all strained in Freehold? And did they not suffer in Shrewsbury? was their not a Barrel of Pork rolled out of one of their Cellers in Shrewsbury, because they refused in any sense to have a hand in the Wars of Albany? And yet, all this Time of their Innocence, they did not forget their Interest, but did become Negro-Masters.
I know Practice and Example will go a great way in Education, and why should it not go as [Page 18] far in Argument? and if it do, I have the less to do but make a short Review how I have Prove by the Practice and Example of all that diversity of Sects of our American Christians, and lastly and mainly by our American Quakers.
Now, if what I have said do not amount to perfect Proof that we may make Slaves of Negros, or any other that we can get the Mastery over, I think the Roman-Catholicks forever may be silent to bring in the Example and Agreement of the East and West-Orthodox, to be a Proof in that Point of the Real Presence.
Christians Answer. There is a good Body o [...] People without the Bounds of your Instance and that is the German-Quakers, who live in German-Town near Philadelphia, Who to their renowned Praise be it spoken) have above all other Sects in America, kept their Hands clean from that vile Oppression and inriching Sin of making Slaves of their fellow Creatures, the Negros, as I was credibly informed by one of themselves, and so have particular Men of all Sects kept themselves free from this inriching sin.
But now I come to your Instance of Ninety Two, that the Quakers were all Innocent then, excepting one Man. This amounts to no more then this, that they were an excellent People in that day, far exceeding other Sects of Christians, and yet were most shamefully overtaken with this inriching Sin, in breaking Christs Command in making Slaves of Negros, which they would be loath to be done by. Ay, but I have a further Reply to make to you upon that [Page 19] Head (which I think will utterly overturn all that you have said upon it) The Quakers had before that Time, embraced Magistracy, which cannot be upheld without the Carnal Sword, whereby they being apostatized from their primitive Innocency and Purity, and become, in that like the rest of the World, it is no Wonder to see them in a Practice so ag [...]eable to it, in making Slaves of their fellow Creatures for their Gain and Advantage.
For it was the making Slaves of Negroes, to inrich themselves, and the embracing of Magistracy, which could not be excecuted without the carnal Sword, which were the two pincipla Baits that Catched many of that once most Worthy People.
Thus far the Negro-Master and the Christian in in after Ages.
And now, Christ an Reader, If thou hast any tender Love to that harmless Lamb, the innocent Messiah, and his harmless and innocent Gospel, thou canst not but see that the making Slaves of Negros is an abominable Anti-Christian Practice. And ( Christian) I will tell thee, It will be very much if I get not a Lash with their Tongues, as they used to lash the Backs of their Slaves (and that I doubt not was with little Mercy some times) especially when there is such an Affront as this offered to their most beloved black Diana.
There is one thing more, and then I think to take my leave at present, of our Negro-Masters, and that is, I earnestly invite them to [Page 20] Repentance; But how to attain to their Repentance, is the Question, for such a heinous sin; for they will find it to be a sin of the Second Table, that is, in plainer words a sin against God and Man both; And I am of Opinion, that such Sins cannot be repented of without Restitution made to them that they have wronged; for until the Cause he removed, I know not how the Effect should cease. But they that live and dye without making Restitution to them that they have wronged, how they can expect the Forgiveness of God, I leave this to the Reader to judge, and then they cannot blame the Writer for a false Construction. But if it should happen that a Reader should construe, that if the Negro-Masters do not make Restitution to the Negroes for the wrong that they have done them, the Forgiveness of God cannot well be obtained, and then leave it to the Negro-Masters to judge of the Consequence.
The next thing that comes into Consideration, What and if our Negro-Masters should live and dye without making any Restitution at all, to their miserable Slaves whom they have so unjustly wronged? The Question then will be, Whether they may expect ever any Restitution at all? I Answer This Question in the Affirmitive, That they may certainly expect it.
But for the further understanding of this Answer, I suppose then that God hath allotted unto all Mankind an Inheritance of Eternal Life, and has written their Names in the Book of Life, and this appears by the frequent mentioning [Page 21] of it in Scripture, of the blotting their Names out of the Book of Life, which could not be, except their Names were first written therein; and so all Men may expect to enjoy their Fathers Gift, the Inheritance of Eternal Life, except they forfeit the same in sinning against God, or sinning against God and Man, and then their Names are blotted out, as God said unto Moses, Him that sinneth against me, him will I blot out.
And now I come to the Restitution again, and say, It cannot stand with the Justice of God that the Negroes or the wronged shall have no Restitution at all; and seeing then that they must be restored of the Wrongs that they have suffered, it must be restored out of the Property of him that hath wronged them; and this Property is his Interest of Eternal Life; and such a proportion of this as will be equivolent to the Wrongs done unto the Negroes or any others, must go to make up this Restitution; for they will have it.
For they will have it made up out of your Portion in Glory, if you have any left for your selves; and if you have not, you may expect so much the more Torment; and if the Negros or Wronged have no Portion left in Glory to be increased by it, they may expect to have so much the less Torment;
For God will right all Wrongs, and do Justice between all his Creatures; and what is not in our Power, God doth not require, but he will not forgive what we have in our Power to amend, [Page 22] and will not do it, so Reason says. And this is the Period of that Branch, the Doing Wrong to Man; But the other Branch, viz. The Sinning against God, our Negro-Masters cannot make Restitution to God for the Sin committed against him, and therefore must Suffer the Punishment due for such a Sin; and I know no way for our Negro Masters to escape any thing of this, so long as the Attributes of God are Righteousness and Justice, Except they Repent and make Restitution.
But if any Negro Master should dislike any thing of this my Answer, I grant him the Liberty which I take, and that is, to answer it himself; And if they have any Truth on their side, I desire them to bring it to the open View of all Men.
Reader, I here also present thee with the Christian Labours of another Hand, and also that Answer, called, The Athenian Oracle, first printed at London And I think to end with the saying of the Wise man, That A three- [...]old Cord is not easily broken.
Arguments against making Slaves of Men.
Argument I.
THE using Mens Labour, and not paying them the Value of it ( except the Labourer gives it) is unjust and therefore unlawful.
But the making Slaves of Men (whether Negroes, Indians, or others) is Using their Labour, and not paying them the Value of it.
Therefore the making Slaves of Men is unlawful.
Arg. 2. Violence is (in ordinary Cases) unlawful, But making Slaves of Men (against their [...]) is Violence.
Therefore making Slaves of Men, is unlawful.
Arg. 3. Punishing Men without Respect to any [...] they have done, is unlawful.
But making Slaves of Negros, is punishing Men without Respect to any Evil they have done, Therefore the Making Slaves of Negros [...] unlawful.
We should think it a sore Punishment to be made Slaves our selves
Arg 4. To make men Prisoners, who have [...] no Law, is (in ordinary Cases) unlawful. But to make Slaves of Negros, is to make men Prisoners, who have broke no Law to deserve [Page 24] it. Therefore to make Slaves of Negros is unlawful.
Arg. 5. Compelling Men to that which will surely bring them to Punishment, is unjust and unlawful.
But making Slaves of Negros, is compelling men to that which will surely bring them to Punishment. Therefore making Slaves of Negros is unlawful.
It is a general Observation among the Negro Masters, that Negros will not be good without often Beating, and that may be (many times) very severe.
Arg. 6. To banish men their Country, who have committed no Fault to deserve it, is unlawful.
But to make Slaves of Negros, is to banish men their Country, who have committed no Fault to deserve it. Therefore, to make Slaves of Negros is unlawful.
Arg. 7. The necessary laying before Men Temptations to sin, is sinful and unlawful.
But making Slaves of Negros, is a necessary laying before men Temptations to Sin. Therefore the making Slaves of Negros, is sinful and unlawful.
Experience proves this, by the Scores of Negros that have murdered themselves, for no other cause but because they were made Slaves and banished their Country.
Arg. 8. Man-stealing (deserves Death by the Law of GOD, and) is unlawful.
But making Slaves of Negroes is Man-stealing. Therefore making Slaves of Negros is unlawful.
[Page 25] Arg. 9. Parting Man and Wife (procures Gods Curse, and) is unlawful.
But making Slaves of Negros is (often times) Parting Man and Wife. Therefore making Slaves of Negros is unlawful; and Those that buy them, partake in the Sin.
Object. They are Heathen, and make no Scruple of it in their own Country.
Answer. The more need to avoid doing those things which harden them in their Heathenish Wickedness, and to avoid partaking with them, and making them Worse.
Arg. 10. That which brings People into unnecessary Danger of their Lives, is unlawful.
But making Slaves of Negros, brings People into unnecessary Danger of their Lives. Therefore making Slaves of Negros, is unlawful.
How many live in Dangers, and how many have lost their Lives by their own and their Neighbours Negros? For they knowing themselves Slaves, care little for their Lives, and fear little those Offences for which they must be put to Death.
Arg. 11. That which cannot be done without Cruelty, is unlawful.
But making Slaves of Men for gain, cannot be done without Cruelty. Therefore making Slaves of Men for Gain, is unlawful.
We should account it the greatest Cruelty and Robbery to be so dealt by ourselves.
Arg. 12. The using Men as if they were Beasts, is unlawful.
But making Slaves of Negros, is using Men as if they were Beasts.
[Page 26] Therefore making Slaves of Negros, is unlawful.
Arg. 13. To deface the Image of GOD, is unlawful.
But Robbing Men of their Freedom, is Defacing the Image of GOD.
Therefore Robbing Men of their Freedom, is unlawful.
Arg. 14. To make Slaves of those to whom our Saviour has commanded that his Gospel should be preached, is unlawful;
But to make Slaves of Negros, is to make Slaves of those to whom our Saviour has commanded that his Gospel should be preached. Therefore to make Slaves of Negros, is unlawful.
Arg. 15. To encourage others to make Slaves of our fellow Christians, is unlawful.
But to make Slaves of Negros, is to encourage the Mahometans to make Slaves of Christians. Therefore to make Slaves of Negors, is unlawful.
Arg. 16. That which is a Stumbling-block to Unbelievers, and a hinderance to their Conversion is unlawful, and one of the Worst of Evils. But making Slaves of Negros (or indians) is a Stumbling-block to Unbel [...]evers, and a Hinderance to their Conversion. Therefore making Slaves of them, is unlawful, and one of the worst of Evils.
Arg. 17. That which Weakens the Arguments of Christians against the Heathen, and has a Tendency to cause some Weak Christians to turn Mahometan, is unlawful.
But To make Slaves of Negros, does all this. [Page 27] Therefore to make Slaves of Negros is unlawful.
Christians are inexcusably required to make the Innocence of their Lives a strong Argument to convince such as know not the Truth, Mat. 5. v. 16. But by this Violence (which was one of the Sins of the Old World) and other vices, the Heathen will see no more Excellency in our Religion then in their own.
Ar. 18. The doing by others as we would not be done by, is Sinful and unlawful.
But making Slaves of Negros, is doing by others as we would not be done by.
Therefore the making Slaves of Negros, is unlawful.
Arg. 19. That which occasions Men to murder one another, is unlawful.
But making Slaves of Negros, occasions them to murder one another.
Therefore making Slaves of Negros, is unlawful, and one of the Worst of Evils.
The Negros make War, and murder one another to take Captives to Sell for Slaves.
Arg. 20. That which brings a Reproach upon our holy Religion is unlawful.
But making Slaves of Negros, brings a Reproach upon our holy Religion. Therefore the making Slaves of Negros, is unlawful.
Object. Negroes are more happy when Slaves then free.
Answ. If that were true, so are some White Men; but is this a Rule to make them Slaves? But for once, we will suppose what some Men say to be true, That gives a Negro has Freedom and [Page 28] give him the Gallows. It is when they are brought into a Country that does not agree whith their Constitution (as might be largely shown) and this shows it the more unlawful to bring them.
Obj. 2. But they Murder one another, and Tyra [...] Cruelty over their Captives in their own Country; and it is a Merciful Deed to bring them into a Land of Safety, although they be made Slaves by it.
Answ. 1. That is also too much used among Christians, and so the same Argument may be used by the Turks to justify their making Slaves of us.
2. If we can help them and prevent such Cruelty, it ought to be by Teaching them better Examples.
3. Our Taking of their Captives, does encourage them the more in such Practices.
4. By buying their Captives, we become Partakers with them, and harden them by our Example.
5. Let it be put to the Conscience of such as buy them, whether (ordinarily) any part of their Motive be to help the Miserable? or whether it be purely and only for Gain?
Obj. 3. It is better for a Captive to be made a Slave then to be Murdered.
Ans. 1. I never heard that when a Man saved his Neighbours Life, he was to have him or sell him and his Posterity for Slaves. Suppose he were at cost to do it, a less Reward may compensate that
2. Suppose he had never been a Captive but for the sake of your Buying him, And suppose [Page 29] some others have been killed for the sake of the [...]rice, where is the Kindness then?
Obj. 4. Some Men could not get their Living, if it were not for their Negro-Slaves.
Ans. 1 st. Poverty does not make Robbery lawful.
2. Poor Men that cannot get their living without them are not able to buy them.
3. If a man be able to labour, he can so well earn a poor Living (at least) for himself, as his Negro (who cannot labour without Food) can earn a poor Living for himself. And if a Man cannot Labour, his Neighbours are indebted to (God that they) help him.
Obj. 5. A Slave that has a good Master has a more comfortable Life than his Master, he being free from care.
Ans. Your way to prove this Argument is to give up your self and your Children to be Slaves to good Masters, and have nothing of your own, and labour as the Negros do, who have good Masters; For if it be not an Argument for your self, how can you force it to be an Argument for another?
Some Negros by being brought into a Christian Country, learn the Christian Faith, and to some of them it becomes the Means of their Salvation, which does Ten Thousand times compensate the Slavery of their whole Life.
Ans. Some Men that are hanged, are brought to Repentance by the Expectation of their Speedy Death; Is this a Rule to hang all Persons that take little care for their Salvation [Page 30] because GOD sometimes (in his mercy) brings good out of evil?
2. We will acknowledge that such Masters as take a diligent care in this, do far better then such as use their Negros as if they were Cattle.
3. I have not heard of one Master in five hundred that do so much as bring their Slaves to the publick worship of God.
4. Grant that you are instrumental of their Salvation, Is it not Simony in the superlative Degree, when you not only take your Reward of them, and that in this World, and that no less will satisfy you for a little good Counsel, &c. than all they have in the World, and their Children after them? And if you will be paid (so excessively) in this world for this good Work, I know not how you can expect your Reward in the Next.
Obj. 7. Canaan was to be a Servant of Servants.
Ans. 1 st. A Prophesy of what men will do, is neither a Command nor Permission to do it.
[2. It is very unlikely that near one quarter the World [ viz. all the Negros] should be the Posterity of Canaan, who were almost rooted out of the World by Joshua; and also that another Quarter of the World, viz. the Indians of America, should be his Posterity too; yea, and the Indians of the East-Indies also (for which of them also they make Slaves.)
3. It was not said it should be so to the End of the World.
4. The Canaanites were Servants to the Children of Israel (the seed of Shem) in buiding Cities [Page 31] and Raising Cattle for them: and so were the Carthagenians to the Romans (the seed of Japhet) who soon after received the Gospel.
Obj. 8. The Children of Israel had Lisence from GOD to make Slaves of the Heathen.
Ans. 1. This was peculiar to the Jewish Nation, and no part of the Moral Law; and if any Society of Men can produce the like Lisence to them, immediately from God, and prove it, let them keep Slaves also.
2. Then the Church was restrained to that People, but now the Gospel is commanded to be taught unto all People and Nations every where.
Obj. 9. Perhaps one Sort of People (if they object here as they do in another case) will say, There is no place in the Bible that has such Words Thou shalt not make Slaves, &c.
By a Retortion, I would Answer, No place has these Words, Mahomet is a false Prophet, &c.
Motive 1. Riches gotten by wronging the Labourer, is cursed, s [...]e James 5. v. 2,3,4,5. A terrible place to such Men!
Mot. 2. Killing Men, must be punished with Death, because man was created in the Image of God, Gen. 9. v. 3,4,5,6. And Man-stealing must be punished with Death; And why? but because Freedom, which only makes Knowledge useful, is a part of Gods Image.
Mot. 3. If we say, we know him, and keep not his Commandments, we lye, and the Truth is not in us, 1 John 2. v. 4. One of his Commandments is To do as we would be don [...] by, Luk. 6. v. 3.
[Page 32] Mot. 4. There are several Curses applyed to the Effect of making Slaves of Negros, as the Parting Man and Wife, &c.
Mot. 5. There are several Capital Crimes attending it, as Murder, Man-stealing, &c.
Mot. 6. It is a Breach of several Commands at once, As of the Eight, in wronging them of their Labour; of the Ninth, in the Reproach of Slavery; of the Sixth, in Violence and Access to murder; of the Seventh, in Access to Adultery, by parting Man and Wife, and so causing them to marry others; of the First, Second and Third, by bringing a Reproach upon the Name of GOD in our holy Religion, and so hardening Idolaters; in some, of the Fourth, in giving them no Time to play, but on the Lords Day.
Mot. 7. We condemn Robbers as worthy to dye, because they Beat-Men, and sometimes kill them, to take their Money from them. And we beat the Negros, and take them Captives, and banish them from their Country forever, and take their Wives and Children from them, and sometimes Cause their Death, and all to get their Labour from them; which is as much worth as their Money. Can the greatest Robbers and Pyra [...]es Out-vi [...]us?
Mot. 8. How will our Religion look among the Heathen! who can judge of it, and of God and of Christ (in whom we believe?) no other way then by our Practice. Is this the way to win them? which we are bound to endeavour; But can we expect it, while we appear to them the Worst of Men!
[Page 33] Can we think that God will take this Reproach to his Name, and his Truth, and not be satisfied in taking Vengeance upon us. And that it may be in the [...]ight of the Heathen.
Mot. 10. What a Cursed Gain will this be, if [...] be the Price of Immortal Souls! Had we instead of Giving them the Worst of Examples, endeavoured to learn them Christ, from the Time we first knew their Country, what good night have been done!
Mot. 11. Suppose the Case be yet uncertain, [...] leaving of this Practice, there is no Danger; but who would venture so great injustice upon [...]ncertainty! And stop the Course of the Gospel?
Mot. 12. So long as you do it, not knowing but that it is a sin, so long it is in you a sin; [...] it were in it self innocent, Rom. 14. Ult. [...]woord [...] Proposal. 1. That Subscriptions be taken of all Masters that will set their Negros free, and of the Number of Negros so to be set free, that they may be sent to their own Country.
Prop. 2. That Subscriptions be taken, what [...]uch Man (Negro Master, or others) will give [...] defray the Charge of sending the Negros [...]ome.
Prop. 3. That such Negros as had rather serve their Masters, then go home, may be kept still it being their Free Act, and it not being safe [...] have them free in this Country)
Prop. 4. That the uttermost Pains be taken [...] instruct them in the Principles of Christian [...]eligion, that (if by the Grace of God they [Page 34] may be Savingly converted) they may be instrumental to convert their Country-Men [...] home; And who knows how much God may bless such Pious Designs, and how much [...] Christian self denying Example may conduce [...] open the Eyes of those poor Heathen.
And such as are savingly converted, the lo [...] of Christ will constrain them to do their utmost [...] convert their Countrey-Men when they come to them.
Mot. 13. If this Course be instrumental t [...] save one Soul, it will a thousand times counte [...] vail the Cost.
Mot. 14 The least we part with for the Cause of Christ shall have an hundred sold Reward beside Eternal-Life, see Mat. 10. ult. Mark. [...] v. 30.
Mot. 15. What Pains will men take, and cross the Ocean for worldly Gain! If we will not do something like it for Spiritual, it is a sign [...] have no part therein, See Mat. 6. v. 21. &c.
Mot. 16. What Glory will it be to Eternity to have been instrumental toward saving on [...] Soul? How much more, toward saving many [...] see Dan. 12. v. 3. &c.
Mot. 17. It would be a sad thing in the Day of Judgement to have mens Undoing their whole life, to answer for.
Mot. 18. I know of no other way to make them Restitution for the wrong done then (but th [...] Cost of sending them home to be part, if they desire it) and without Restitution (where it is possible and the Wrong known [Page 35] we know of no Pardon, See L. [...]it. 6. v. 4, 5, 6. &c.
Mot. 19. We disgrace our selves, and our Religion, shewing our selves to be partial and unreasonable, We condemn the Turks for making Slaves of us, and we make Slaves of others. We condemn and punish our Negros for seeking by [...]unning away to get their Freedom, and yet we should justify our selves, and one another, in doing the same, if we were Slaves to the Turks, or any others.
Now, if any one can answer all this, and keep a good Conscience in it, I am content. But if that be done, I have one Motive more.
Mot. 20. When the Country grows full of People, and also abounds which Negros, poor People will want Imploy, and must either beg or steal for their Living, which will be no pleasant thing to Rich or Poor; and Rich mens Children are sometimes Poor (especially if their Estate be gotten by Wronging the Labourer) and (if they Regard not the Honour of GOD) I believe they would be loath to have their Children hanged for Thieves.
But I am amazed to think Christians (so called) who keep Negros as if they were Cattle, and had no Soul! Who neither Teach them themselves, nor bring them to Gods Worship, As if they feared the loss of their Money by their Negros Salvation.
These Things I ofter to Consideration, desiring [Page 36] wise Men to give their Judgment; so I have no desire to hinder my Country-Men [...] any Lawful Gain, but cannot believe it lawful to make men Slaves, but I see all these Arguments fully answered, Except they ha [...] rather be Slaves, than to go home to their own Country.
THE Athenian Oracle, The Second Edition, Printed at London. 1704. Vol. 1. Pag. 545—548.
Quest. W Hether Trading for Negros, i. e. carrying them out of their own Country into perpetual Slavery, be in it self Unlawful, and especially contrary to the great Law of Christianity?
Ansm. Sir, After a mature and serious consideration of the Question proposed, I am for the Affirmative, and cannot see how such a Trade (tho' much used by Christians) can be any way justify'd, and fairly reconciled to the Christian Law. And here, first let me propose my Reasons, and then Answer such weak Pleas [...] use to be made for it.
1. I take it to be contrary to the great Law of Nature, of doing unto all Men as we would they should do unto us; and which, as our Saviour [Page 38] tells us (Mat. 7. 22. 22.) Is the sum of the [...] and the Prophets. For let us put the Case to ourselves, and consider what it would be for a Ma [...] to be stolen away from his Native Country and hurryed into perpetual Bon [...]age; Or to hav [...] a Child snatch'd from his Embraces, and so used and then see if this Trade and practice can be any way reconciled to this Rule. And surely they that have the Gospel, and yet sin against the very Laws of Nature; shall have a severe punishment at the Day of Judgment, than those poor [...]illy Wretches that have only that di [...] Light to guide them. And perhaps those poor Wretches in Chains, when Death shall make them free; may rise up in Judgment, and condemn those more cruel and unnatural Men tha [...] so unjustly deprive them of that Liberty which GOD and Nature had given them.
2. 'Tis plainly contrary to the Word of God and forbidden both in the Old Testament, and in the New; See Exod. 21. 16. He that stealth a Man and seileth him, or if be found in his hands he shall be surely put to Death. The prohibition is general; He that Stealeth any Man whatsoever, without distinction; whether one of their Brothers, or a Stranger; a meer Heathen, or a Pagan: He shall be surely put to Death; the punishment is Capital, and good reason for it. For if he that sheddeth Mans blood, by Man shall his blood be shed: surely Liberty is as dear as Life it self. Yea, he that intends to sell a Man into some kind of Bondage, would do him a greater kindness to free him from a [Page 39] miserable Life. And I am well assured, this is [...] case of some of those poor Wretches, with a witness.
Again, In the New-Testament St. Paul, 1 Tim. 10. joyns the Man-stealer with the most [...] and unnatural Sinners; Murderers of Fathers, and Murderers of Mothers, and Def [...]lers of themselves with Mankind.
3. Its Practice is a Disgrace to Christianity, [...] makes the Name of Christ to be blasphem'd amongst the Gentiles, and (in all likelihood) hinders the Propagation of the Christian Faith [...] the World. For I am verily perswaded, that [...] a fair and honest Trade and Commerce had been carried on amongst them, and no violence [...] been done to their persons: Christianity must have gotten as great footing by this time amongst them, as it has amongst the poor In [...]dels of New-England: Or, at least, they might have been in a great forwardness to receive that holy Doctrine; which now they hate and abominate for the sake of this practice of Christians amongst them.—And Wo be to that Person, that shall by any means hinder that blessed design for which Christ came from Heaven; and both Himself, his Apostles, and many Primitive Christians spent their dearest blood to promote; viz. to have the Mind and Will of GOD known unto the World.
But perhaps some may make light of this, and perswade themselves, they have sufficient pleas to vindicate the Practice. I know indeed many times, when a man's Interest lies in the [Page 40] Ballance; a very weak Plea and light Ex [...] will pass for a weighty Reason: But for [...] part (who am a person indifferent, and altogether unconcern'd that way) I could never [...] receive any Answer or Excuse that could rais [...] in me the least doubt of the Unlawfulness of i [...]—That which I have heard pleaded for it, [...] to this Effect; viz.
Plea 1. We deny the Charge, we do not Steal them: but make a lawful Purchase of them.
Ans [...]. Purchase them (for Toyes and Baubles perhaps you may: but lawful I am sure you cannot. For they which Sell them do Steal them, or take them away by violence. And you know the Proverb, The Receiver is as bad as the Stealer. We are they that call our selves Christians, that Encourage them in such Evil Practices. Our Law (in many Cases) looks upon the Accessary as bad as the Thief. I am sure the Law of God does Prov. 29. 24. Whos [...] [...] Partner with a Thief, hateth his own Soul. And the holy Psalmist charges it as a great crime, whe [...] we see a Thief, to consent with him, Psal. [...] 18. The Learned and Pious Bishop Hall, in his Decade of Cases of Conscience, Decade 1. Ca [...] 10. p. 66. Resolves this Case; That to buy those Goods, which we know, or have just cause to suspect, are stoln or plunder'd; is no better than to make our selves accessary to the Thief; If you do it with an intention to possess them as your own ( i. e. not return them to the right Owner) For what do you else but [...] [Page 41] facto, partake with that Thief which stole them, and encourage him in his loud practices; since, according to the old Word, If there were [...]o Receivers, there would be no Thieves.
Plea 2. But most of them are taken Prisoners of War, by one petty Prince from another; and sold by the Conquerour.
A. But who are commonly the cause of this War, or what do they commonly [...]ight about, but to gain the Booty of the Field; Slaves to be Sold?—And I am credibly inform'd, 'tis usual for the Traders in this unlawful Commodity, to send Presents to some petty Prince among them, to make War with his Neighbouring Prince, to take such Prisoners, and furnish their Cargo: And who then must answer for all this Blood and Injustice?
Plea 3. Those Men are more Heathens than Pagans?
A. Pray, What then? What have we to do with them? Have they not a common Right to those Temporal Blessings, which an indulgent Creator has given them, as well as we? Is Dominion founded in Grace? May a man that is pleas'd to call himself a Christian, under that Notion, wrong or molest such as had not the Happiness to be born in a Christian Country? Did our Lord and Master (tho' the Lord of the whole World) give us any such Example, when in the World? And do [...]h not the Apostle bid us do good unto all Men, and especially to the houshold of Faith? Tho' we ought to be kinder to our Brother Christian; yet surely we [Page 42] ought to do good; or, at least, to do no wrong to meer Pagans and Infidels.
Plea 4. Did not the Jews buy Slaves? How often do we read of the Bond-Servant bought with their Money in the Jewish Law? And may we not do what God's own People did?
A. I answer, First, in the general, That the Judicial Law of Moses (whereof this about Bond-Slaves, is one) is made void, and no Rule, (further than it carries a moral Reason with it) for Christians to walk by; who (as says the Apostle) are not under the Law, but under Grace. But,
2dly. Let us deal with those poor Negros as the Jews were comman [...]ed to do with the Heathen. 1. When they had bought them, they were obliged to bring them up in the true Religion. See Gen. 17. 12, 13. God commands Abraham, He that is born in thy House, or bought with Money of any Stranger which is not thy seed; such an one must needs be Circumcised, and brought into Covenant with GOD. 2. Whilst they were in the House, they were to be kind and loving towards them; and tis often repeated, Be kind unto Strangers, for you yourselves were Strangers in the land of Egypt.
Plea. 5 The Law of our Land al [...]ows it.
A. The Law of our Land is so far from allowing it, that if an Infidel be brought into this Kingdom, as soon as he can give an Account of the Christian Faith, and desires to be Baptized; any Charitable lawful Minister may do it: and then he is under the same Law with other Christians [Page 43] —As for our Islanders abroad; from whence they came, who carried them thither, and what kind of Christians the most of them are; need not inform you. 'Tis their great Diana, by this Craft they have their aim. And therefore we can never expect that they should make any private or By- Laws against it. But if the Law be ever to much silent in this Case; He that will do any thing that the Law (which can never provide in all Cases) does not plainly forbid: would be but a bad Subject, and I'm sure, a Worse Christian.
Lastly, They say, They thereby make them, those useless Creatures, to become greatly advantagious to Mankind; bring them into a happier Condition: and many of them become good Christians. &c.
A. How dare we pretend to order things better than an All-Wise Lawgiver has plainly commanded us? Or think to put those poor Wretches to better Uses, than an all-wise Providence seems as yet, to have design'd them for? If they came freely, what need a Cargo be carried to purchase 'em? What need of Chains, and Bolts, and Fetters? And why do many of those poor Wretches endeavour to starve, or destroy themselves, or leap over-board: If so mighty glad of being carried into perpetual Slavery? Or if they find themselves happier under their Bondage, than in their own Country, what is the reason that when one of their Fellow-Slaves dyes, all the rest sing, and rejoyce, and dance about him, as foolishly concluding he [Page 44] is happily returned to his own Country? And th [...] some of them may be admitted to become Christians, 'tis more than the Seller knows, or any was obliges the Purchaser to; Neither can that [...] for the rest. And surely, methinks, what ha [...] been said, should be enough to convince all such as are not resolved before-hand, that they will not be convinced: or at least, to render the Case extraordinary dubious; and then the safe [...] part is to be chosen; especially in this Case where (if we are afterward convinced we have done those poor Wretches any wrong) We can never make them Restitution.