THe Nobleness of Parentage, by the Laws of Honour, entales on Posterity (with other Rights) a protection from all incivilities, but not from the austere Demands of Justice, when that is affronted and violated. Justice keeping the Golden Rule (
Quo dat Suum Cuique) observes no other Destinctions, than what it first makes in its Distributions amongst the Rich and Poor, the Noble and Ignoble, it is no Respecter of Persons, for that it is Superiour to all men, and sits as a veiled Empress holding the Ballance to weigh out equal to each one according to the Merits of the cause, and sees no man.
There being now under Cognisance, such as are of honourable Families, yet arrested and brought by due course of Law to
Answer for high Crimes, it must not be supposed Rudeness in Manners, though they be some-what freely and Rusly handled, whilst the prosecution is held agreeable with the Impeachment and Rule of Justice. And as for
[Page 36] my self, who am under Commission from Authority, to appear in Defence of my Countries Sacred Liberties,
I can in my own Justification, affirm, That I have no dishonourable Inclinations, but carry a Just mind, so as to Condemn no Man or thing, but upon plain evidence, nor to agravate any Plea beyond its just Bounds.
Therefore, tho' in the following pages there may be discerned a great Liberty in Argument, with a mixture of Satyres, as tho' none by my Inferiours were Involved in the Charge, Yet ascribe it unto my love and veneration for so great an Interest as I appear for, and not to any base intent of sinking the honour or darkning the Luster of better Men. I neither desire nor design to hurt any Man, No, not so much as an hair on his head, but
I Solely aim at ERROR, that is the But
I Level for.
Thus having by this brief, but sincere Apology secured the Honour of my Intentions, if I am worthy of belief, I shall no longer interrupt the Process, but shall
nextly, draw up the Indictment, upon which these Proposals are to pass, and abide a Tryal.
1▪ As Introductory, and for the bringing in further Evidences against the Criminal Proposals, now upon their Tryal, I offer these following Queries.
5. Query.
We must needs then enquire,
From whence the Proposals
derive their force? Who gives them Letters of Attorney or Commission to sue these Churches (by a
Quo Warranto) out of Possession of their Government? To me (I must needs confess) the Attempt is very Daring; and I see no way of Reconcilation, unless the Scheme drawn in the
Proposals can be fairly sheltered under some more authentick and specious Umbrage, than the bold Dictates, though of the Wisest of men, when they are pleased to set themselves up Oracles for their Country. So I come,
2. To the more Critical Examination of the
Proposals themselves, which I shall Attend,
- 1. More Generally.
- 2. More particularly, by taking a survey of them in their distinct Sections.
1. More Generally, by Inquiring into their Original, and nature.
1. By making a more Exact Inquest and search after their Original, and in this debate they forfeit their Essence, unless they can derive their Essence, unless they can derive their Pedigree, either
1. From Gods Immediate Inspiration. Or,
2. From Antient Revelation. Or,
[Page 45]3. From Right Reason, which is a Ray of Divine Wisdom instampt upon Humane nature. Or,
4. From the
Platform of the Churches, which is a systim of Government, collected by our Ancestors out of several Fountains, and Principally from the Scriptures. Now in pursuing this Distribution, I shall diligently enquire, whether we can hear of their Original under any of these heads.
1. As to Immediate Inspiration, I must needs presume, these Gentlemen will not dare to Assert, that they are sent Immediately from God with this Message to the Churches; they are too good and wise to pretend (with
Enthusiasts) to Immediate Vision, or a spirit of Prophecy; both the matter and manner of their writing sufficiently convinces, that these
Proposals are their own Sentiments; they durst not put, a
Thus saith the LORD upon them; such on Inscription is too Heavenly and Royal for such Coyn: for both they and we know, according to
Dut. 30.12. it is not in Heaven, that thou shouldest say, who shall go up for us to Heaven, and bring it unto us, that we may know and do it? there is no need to send Messengers to that Court, to learn by Immediate and Extraordinary Information, either the Laws of our Duty or Interest; for that God hath made all things sufficiently plain, by this Time of day, either by Scripture or Reason, for the Conduct and Government of his Churches, yea, of the subjects of his Universal
[Page 46] Intellectual MONARCHY in this World.
2. As to the Antient Revelation; Holy Scripture, that best, tho' not the bigest of Books, is the saints Library, and the Clergy-mans Pandects, whence he takes the Rules for the Mannagment of his Trust; so that it is very Amusing that the Bible should be forgotten in Drawing up such Schemes as these; as tho' the usage of the Popes Conclave, which turns the Bible out of doors for a Wrangler, and gives the chief Seal to Tradition, &c. were here in fashion. Indeed, I cannot but esteem them very unfortunate Proposals to be turned so naked into the World, as not to have the least tincture of Scripture to Gaurd them from Contempt; no, not so much as a Citation, that might admit of so much as a strained Consequence in their Defence. And so, tho' less Prophane, yet they are also less Politick then the most desperate of Hereticks, who alwayes bring their Errors on the stage guarded with Scriptures, and craftily Indeavour to make their Citations look with such an aspect, as tho' they were encampt on their side. But here we have nothing for our Faith to lean on, but so many austerer
Ipse Dixits, as bitter Pills of Death for the Churches to Swallow, without any of the Confection of Heaven or the Sweet Manna Sprinkled upon them; or else only so many naked Humane Persumptions, as Arrows or Bolts, too Rashly shot out against the sides of our Churches, and no word of Scripture to Tip or feather them. Nay, it is very Memorable, and I account fatal,
[Page 47] and to be observed, that GOD, that secret Title of the Almighty, with which the Holy Scripture does so abound, is not once named (as I can find) in the whole Treatise; as tho' the most sacred Titles, as well as Sections of that heavenly Book, would move Fears and irritate Jealousies, rather then pouer down Solace and Comfort upon this Undertaking. Therefore, in a word, the whole Bible is thrown by as a Sealed Parchment, or as one that never Prophecies good to such Adventurers. Therefore these
Proposals being apprehended as Sea Rovers, and Indicted upon the
statute of Pyracy, and upon Examination being found without the Prince of Princes Colours and yet doing great mischief, in Assaulting and Wounding his Churches and Lawful Subjects, on their honest occasion, being bound on a Voyage to their own Country, they can no ways in Justice escape, but must Pass under the Sentence, and endure the Pains of Death, for they were taken Fighting without Commission.
3.
As to REASONS.
Recta Ratio, Right Reason, that great Oracle in Humane Affairs is the Soul of Man, so formed or endowed by Creation with a certain Sagacity or Acumen (in many perticular Examples sharpned by the constitution of nature, by Grace and study) whereby mans Intellect is inabled to take up (
pro Medulo or in a degree) the true Idea or Perception of things, agreeable with and according
[Page 48] to their Natures. So that if we bring these Proposals under Examination by the Laws of Reason, we must enquire whether they are agreeable with the nature and Constitution of the Churches, if they fully harmonize with their Principles of Essence, then they may be enroled for Canons; but if they Jar and are plainly Repugnant, we may then Lawfully censure them, and pronounce them Irrational. Whether these Churches are constituted by Scripture or Reason, yea or no, that is not our Question, but being of such a Frame or Constitution, as they now are, and always have been, all who pretend to Support and preserve them, and yet take such measures, as will utterly overthrow and dissolve them, such Repairers have apparently deserted the Dictates and Government of Right Reason.
And here we may Collect an Induction of some few hints of certain particulars for Evidence; the Platform Asserts a Classes to be no Gospel form of Church Order;
The Proposals say it is, or they abuse our Credulity.
The Proposals Order the Association to have the first Cognizance of Church Cases; our Government says, No, it belongs to the Jurisdiction of particular Churches. The Proposals give Power to the Association to limit Elections, and to Direct them; but our Government says, No, it will not Consent; the Election of Officers is the Prerogative of the Churches, and they wont, as yet, part with it, &c. So that when we can by the Rules of Grammer Resolve yea or no, yea or nay, to
[Page 49] be the same voice and word, then you may Reconcile the
Proposals and the
Plat-form; that Certainly whatever there be of Religion, the Method is apperantly Disagreeable with Common Reason.
4.
As to the PLAT-FORM.
I shall represent it by a kind of a short
Prosopop
[...], thus,
viz. enquiring whether the Proposals are deduced from this fountain, the
Plat-form with all its Chapters, and with one joynt Consent, as plain as the Tongue in their heads can utter it, say, that never since it Possest the Government, so much as Dream'd of them. It may say with destruction (
Job 28.22.) we have heard of the Fame of these things, with our Ears, but never Imagined so much as a seminal vertue in our own being, for their Procreation, but rather starts with the News of their approach, out of fear of its own Dissolution from their Repugnant and formidable nature. Therefore as in a grievous fright, from Surprize, Crys out with
Athaliah, Treason, Treason! And Begs that Zeal and Conscience, those two Solicitors for the Crown, will at this Grand Court of
Oyer and
Terminer Implead and Prosecute them as Traytors to the Prince of Peace, and Fellons to these Churches, Christs Loyal Subjects. So I come,
2. To enquire into the nature of these
Proposals, by Surveying their Composition and Properties.
1
st. Their Composition.
[Page 50]They seem a Conjunction of almost all the Church Governments in the World, and the least part is Congregational. Indeed at the first Cast of the Eye, the Scheme seems to be the
Spectre Ghost of Presbiterianism, or the Government or of the Church by Classes; Yet, if I don't mistake, in Intention there is something Considerable of
Prelacy in it, only the distinct Courts of
Bishop with the
Steeples of the
Churches, Tythes, Surplice and other Ornaments, do not shew themselves so visible, as to be discerned at the first look; yet with a Microscope you may easily discern them really to be there in
Embrio, Et in Rera nature; for this is a known Maxim,
Quod necessario Subintelligitar non Deest, What is necessarily understood, or lies hid in the Intention of a Design, is Really here, by just Interpretation; Therefore these Proposals
which dare Revolt so far at a step, as these have done, must needs understand no less in their aim, than of an Enobling Government for Clergy-men, which our Princes and Parliaments have adorned the Churches with. This seems Rational, that those which never stick at Robbing the Churches of such an Immence Treasure, as the Proposals carry off, will
never stand, Shall we! Shall we! at the offer of a Bishoprick, which is a Barrony with all its Rights and Royal Appurtenancies.
There is also something in it which
Smells very strong of the Infallible Chair, To Assume the Power of making Rules, to Ingross all Principles of Process, The Right of Election, the last Appeal, The Negative Vote, and all Super-Intending
[Page 51] Power in Matters Ecclesiastick, as the Prerogatives of Clergy-men, Distinct from all other Estates and Ministers in Government; or thus for the Clergy to Monopolize both the Legislative and Executive part of Cannon Law, is but a few steps from tht Chair of universal Pestilence, and by the Ladders here set up,
Clergy-men may, if they please, Clamber thus high, for when they are invested with what is in these Proposals provided and intended for them, who then can controul them but the Almighty himself? as was said of those daring men,
Gen. 11.6. And now nothing will be Restrained from them which they have Imagined to do; for who can now with-hold from them Infallibility, or stop the Direful and Definitive Sentence? Who can limit their Power or shorten their Arm in their Executions? Their Bulls can now, upon any any affront, Bellow and Thunder out a Thousand terrible Curses, and the poor affrighted and Invassal'd Layity, both Princes and Subjects (being here as in the grave put under one and the same Topick) must forfeit their Salvation, if they don't tamely submit, and obediently become their Executioners; for that it is now evident that all Power is, if not Really given, yet formally stollen, and in Intent Bequeathed to them.
2
dly. Their Properties.
1
st Property, is
Disorder Order is both the Beauty and safety of Universe, take aside the
[...]
[Page 52] whereby the whole hangs to gether, the great Frame of nature is unpin'd and drops piece from piece; and out of a Beautiful structure we have a Chaos. These Proposals are therefore very mischievous, if not in matter, yet in the manner of Production; they are full of Disorder, being things born out of due time, their Conception is without Countinance, from the Rule of Order. Indeed there is no Statute to be found that will justify the first Coitus of Parents, neither will any allow their Social Life; that the Birth must bear the Attender, of being both begotten and Born, out of Lawful Wedlock, and so in Point of Honour fall under the Censure of the
Levitical Law, and must be kept back from Promotion, for
Deut. 32.
A Bastard shall not enter into the Congregation.
That to pass all other Remarks, if we are under mistake in the assertions, I then demand and enquire, Where is that Lawful Authority which Published Legal Banes, with the Consent of all the Interested Persons, and the regular Consumation of the Match? If any Rule can be found to shelter and Honour the Conception and Birth, let it be produced, and it escaping other Felonies with Life, this Scandal shall be taken off, but otherwise it must remain as a Bar to the tenth Generation.
The 2
d Properity Is
Ʋsurpation. The Proposals Apparently Usurp the Churches Prerogatives. It has been asserted, and it is true, These Churches have been Settled upon the Plat-form of their own
[Page 53] Government for upwards of
Sixty Years; they have often Revised and Re-inforc'd the Establishment, both as the Principles of their Consociation and Union in General, and the Form of Government for every Church in particular. Then, for these Proposals without Licence to assume a Legislation, and form a Government, so repugnant to their own, can be no less then Usurping a Dominion over them, contrary to the Rule, 1
Pet. 5.3. neither as being Lords over Gods Heritage. Lesser Acts against Empire hath cost many a bold man his head; What! for a
particular kno
[...] or Juncto of Gentlemen to make so bold with a settled Government, as to pick out all the Enobling Royalties, Liberties and Enfranchizements in it, and Sacrifice them to their own Ambition! It is enough to put mankind into an Uproar.
It is fresh in Memory, that when some of our English Princes (and one would think, if any men may, they may be allowed to aspire, yet when they) have Presumed on less things than these Proposals reach after, in gratifying their Aim at an Absolute Monarchy, when as they have not dared to lay out with such freedom, a new Form of Government, with a wide mouth, gaping to devour the
English Liberties, (as these Proposals do the Churches, but only with much secrecy, covin and Pollicy, they have by some more Clandestine measures been Intruding upon the antient Liberties of the English Nation) Every one knows what direful Convultions this has bred in the Bowels of the Kingdom. And may it not
[Page 54] serve to enliven this Plea? To invite all such who are with
Plato, Owners of a great Genius at Inventing new or Modeling old Governments, to try their Skill in altering the English Monarchy, and see how it will be Probated. That is, suppose you should venture to Interdict the
Royal Assent, or Convert the present Monarch into a Duke of
Venice, or dissolve the Lords in Parliament or (rather in Harmony with this Scheme) Turn the Burgesses and Knights of the Shires (as a sort of men not fit for Politicks in Parliament) out of doors? And whether our Soveraign, the Peerage, or Subjects of English Liberties would take it well? And whether Christian men may make Bolder with the Established Government of Christs Churches, then with that which belongs to Civil Affairs? In Honour to the
New-England Churches, and with veneration for the
English Monarchy, I dare assert, that there is in the Constitution of our Church Government more of the English Civil Government in it, and it has a better Complexion to suit the true English Spirit, than is in the
English Church, or any other, both as to the Legislative and Executive part of Government. Indeed, considering how things are at home in Church and State, I have been sometimes ready to Query, Why the Nation should be so Enamored with their Civil, and yet so Careless and Regardless of their Gospel Liberties, so as to Trust their Consciences with their Clergy, more immediately, and yet won't venture their Estates with their Learned Judges,
[Page 55] without the Priviledge and Mediation of Juries; as tho' they were more careful and wise in securing their Estates than their Souls, and valued one far more then the other. But I shall go on with the Comparison.
1. As to the
Legislation; Our New-England Convocation admits, and the Government does profess the fraternity as necessary to the being of all Synodical Assemblies, that as far as Legislation, spiritual, is left to men, and as they have a great Treasure,
viz. Their
Salvation Imbarqued, so they have a great Interest in the Management of it; and herein they agree with the English Caution and Wisdom, in the Modes of Civil Government of the Empire; for the Commons are one great state in the Civil Legislation; and as they have a great Power in the mannagement of that Great Trust.
2. As to
Administration or the
Executive part of
Government, Our
New-England Government grants a Jurisdical Power to the Fraternity
[...] makes them proper Judges in all Ecclesiastical Cases and Administrations, on Persons Cognizable, or that must pass a Tryal
Juridice; which is agreeable with the Constitution, Nature and Practice of the Civil Government of the Empire; for under the Prosecutions of Law, no
English Subject, in Life, Limb or Estate, must be past upon, but by the Judgment of his
PEERS; Yea, in all Pleas of the Crown, such Confidence has the Government put in the Loyalty and Discretion of the Commons, that our English Juries are
[Page 56] stated Arbitarors and Umpires between our Prince and his Subjects. Yea, such a dependance has the whole Nation in Keeping these Liberties in their own hands, that they Reckon the
Commons in Parliament and
Juries in the
Common Wealth, to be the great Pillars of English Honour and Liberties, and they esteem them as Ramparts built by the Wisdom of our Ancesters, to Defend us from Tyranny and Slavery.
That considering the affinity in these two Constitutions, one would be ready to Query, Whether the Heroick true English Spirit is not Parent to both? Or whether they are not equal Debtors to the Gospel, for their Original? The Improvement of this comparison is briefly this; Suppose some of the great Ministers of State should venture to sweep away all those Civil Enfranchizements which are
English-mens Birth-Right, and set up an Arbitrary Power, with a pretence of doing Justice and Judgment in the Kingdom, by more concise and expedient Measures, whether they might not be seized? And whether the Statutes would not be Chain strong enough to hold them, as
Traytors to a well formed Government, and then laid fast by a Mittimus for great Usurpers? And whether the Plea will not hold in Just Proportions, on the
other side of the Comparison?
3
d. Property Riotous. The nature of
a Riot may (in part) be thus described, it is an
Ʋnlawful Assembly of more than three met in one place to do an Ʋnlawful Ast, as violently breaking down of
[Page 57] Walls, and pulling up of Hedges, and wrongfully entering into mens Rights and Possession, and that in a fray and Terror of the People. In managing this Plea, I shall only desire that the Illegality of the Assembly which formed these Proposals, with the Objects and things they intend, and the ancient Boundaries which they plainly Invade, together with the fearful apprehensions that many good and sober People in the Vicinage have concerning the Enterprize, may be Critically examined, and I doubt not but when we obtain the suffrage of this Honourable Court, it will
Determine, The Impleaded Criminals are of a Riotous nature, and so the INDICTMENT will stand more valed against them.
4
th. Property, Sacriligious, &c.
5
th. Property, Rebellious.
It grieves me to utter the Epethites agreeable with the Nature of these proposals; yet they must Blame their own Nature, but not my Justice, if
I give them but their due; for I find them in the breach of a Royal Statute, yea, I think of a Penal Law. This is plain,
They take away the Liberties, Priviledges, Discipline and Government of these Churches, all which are Established to them by the Law; and that not only by their own Cannons, but by the Laws of this Province, as by a
Royal Magna Charta, viz. in an Act for the Settlement and Support of the Ministers, pag. 3. in these words,
‘
The Respective Churches in the several Towns within this Province shall at all times hereafter use, exercise and enjoy all their Priviledges and Freedoms Respecting
[Page 58] Divine Worship, Church Order, and Discipline, and shall be encouraged in the Peaceable and Regular Profession and Practice thereof.’
This Act (as one says on the great Charter of
English Liberties) Deserves to be
written in letters of Gold, and hung up in all our Houses of Gods Publick Worship, to signalize the Zeal (in the Presence of God, Angels, and Men) of the Authority of the Throne and Empire, for the Establishing of these Churches, and Christs Interest in them. Now, Considering that the Power, Pollicy, and Grace of the English Crown, should
Thus lock up the Churches Treasure for them, and set such a Centinal, with the flaming Sword of Justice in its hand, to Dread and Awe Intrudeeis, it must needs be a very bold Action, (if it ben't Plump Rebellion) to Attempt or design such a Sequestration or Imbezellment as
the proposals DO.
6
th. Property, Ʋnfaithfullness, &c.
7
th. Property, Ingratitude.
For the Stewards of great Families, when Advanced to Honour and a Profitable Trust, by the free Election and Grace of Noble-Men, when their Lords are laid down to rest, and sleep too securely, or are gone out of Town, with this presumption, that their Estate is secure, it being put under the care of Loyal Trustees and Thankful Servants; Now for such Trustees and Stewards, upon such opportunities to Pocket up or load away the Riches of the Family, and set up for themselves, and leave the Proprietors
[Page 59] Beggers, whom they found in Wealth and Plenty, is both Infidelity & Ingratitude. Now let the Churches be pluck't and deplum'd, as the Proposals intend, and they are after the possessing a fair Estate, become Banckrupts; And let
those stewards that are guilty Answer for the Robbery, for my part I will have no share in it.
8
th. Property, Impolicy.
And I am sure there is great store of this in these Proposals; I shall Instance but in two Particulars.
1. In Timing the Challenge that is here made, to Brave a Rich and Powerful Enemy at so great a distance, and invite them by sound of Trumpet to a Pitch't Battle, when Surprize and Ambushments might be laid, and do the work with the Expence but of a tenth part of the Blood which this may cost. This is not agreeable with the Art of War;
Achitophel would have put a Derision upon such Measures.
Jacob's Sons when taking a Bloody design in hand, first contrived to Stupify and blunt the Courage of their Enemies, and then came upon them by Surprize, e're they could Arm in their own Defence (Tho' it does not justifie their Cruelty, yet it magnifies their Subtilty) for thereby they brought their design about, when as if they had gone a more Blunt and daring way to work
Simon and
Levi, had not been half a breakfast for the
Hivites, Gen. 34.25.
So here, had the Churches been Convened, and no noise made of this Design, they Possibly
[Page 60] (tho' their Treasures are fortified by Right, and so in safety, and their Troops more ten to one then their Enemies) yet by ambushments or Surprize they might have chanced to have been Coakered or Conquered out of all, by being flattered, overawed, or over Argued, into a Surrender or Submission; But we may now Rationally hope the Alarm will Rouse the Whole Camp, and each Squadron will Rebound it to the next with a
hinc Proixmus Ʋrit Ʋcalogon; And so the Plot may upon a Defeat, blame its own bad conduct, more than its Fortune.
2
dly. the Design it self (
Quo ad finem Executionis) let it come to Birth, as is Designed, or Desired, and the very Heavens would either frown upon or Laugh at it for its folly; If we Examine the Climate of the Country, the Degrees of Latitude, and the Severe Stars that chiefly govern, There is no good Policy in the Design; so that, me thinks, the Universal frame of nature Cryes it Down for a
Non-Compos mentis; for there are no such great Creatures as are here Conceived, can fare in hard cold Countries as the
Camelion does in warm, there must be a very great hoard to support them; and Nature does honestly Confess, she cannot answer the Bills of Fare, which belong to their Table, and do her Duty to the Royal Exchequer; and this must be Maintained, or all breaks to pieces.
Again, let it be considered, whether it ben't great Intellectual Weakness, or want of Policy, for one Generation to contrive needless Loads
[Page 61] for the next, especially when they may get as well to Heaven without carrying such Packs along the Road? It has been universally the humour of mankind, according to the Laws of Nations and Nature, when Roused by the Regular Dictates of Self-Love, to endeavour that every following Generation might be more lightsome, free, noble and happy than that which did immediately preceed.
They say, the
Chinees dig Clay and use it not, but leave it heapt, or in Pits, mellowing for the next Age. Every Prudent man builds his House for Duration. The Prince enlarges and betters his Dominions. The Peasant sweats to advance his Estate, and then each leaves all in Greater Triumph to their Heirs.
The
Kentish Yeomantry are had in honour to this day, for not stooping to the Conqueror, till they had Conditioned, and thereby secured their fair Estates of Lands in Fee and Free-holds forever from all Forfeiture by Felony, according to their Country proverb,
The Father to the Bough,
The Son to the Plough.
Such is the Mercyful fore-sight of Mankind, and his charitable Care and fore cast for such as shall follow, tho' they may never be seen or Known by their wise Progenitors.
But here is plainly a Conspiracy very Heterogenious to such Judicious Acts of Humane Providence; A Design plainly, if not perfectly to Enslave, yet to bring Posterity into a needless Vassalage and Thraledom.
[Page 62]This is an acknowledged verity amongst wise
Statists, That that Monarch who has the Command of the Seas, can at his Pleasure Command any Maritime Country. And so, those men who have the Command and Empire of the Conscience of Mankind, can Command their Estates, and indeed whatsoever else is grateful to them.
Then, where abouts are we in our Politicks, when we have delivered up the Royalties that are Challenged? and in what a weak Capacity shall we leave Posterity in? Nay, these
Vertuoso's themselves, seem to be hardened with the Ostrich against their Own Natural Issue, unless the thing would chance to spring up as quick as
Jonas Goard, and hang as full of Pearls and Diamonds as the Sea and Rocks of
India, and they themselves shall have the first shake, and fill all their Coffers, with this Harvest, or at least, that they are assured that they can and shall Entail their Offices as securely as their Lands, upon their own Children, as was the Order of Priesthood, and the Fashion of the house of Levi. But alas! these modes are all worn out, and made null; and such mens Sons, as we are now treating of, in with the Multitude, must carry their falling Equal share of the Common Load; that should the Project prevail, under their Mannagement, (might they but look up out of their Graves in about half an Age) They may complain in Elegy, after the manner of
Virgil over his,
Sic vos non vobis. Hos ego versiculos feci, Jubit alter Honorem. These verses I made, but another man carries
[Page 63] away the Honour. So these Gentlemen might e'en say, we have Contrived to greaten the Clergy, and with Bees have filled a Rich Hive, and Built a fair Nest well feathered, but our Posterity, we see, is never the warmer, nor will they lick their fingers of it; and not only so, but are the men that must make up the tenth Sheaf, and deliver the tenth Cock, Calf and Lamb unto others out of their poor Demesnes. And also it may Justly beget a mournful Remembrance in Posterity of their Parents, and make them often look with a sad Countenance upon their Fathers Graves, not because they are Dead, but because they had not ended their days sooner,
viz. before this Scheme (so Oppressive and Cruel to their small Free-holds) had taken effect under their Mannagement.
2. We come now, according to engagement, to take a Survey of the
Proposals in their destinct Sections.
SECT. III. THat Advice be taken by the Associated Pastors, from time to time, ere they proceed to any Action in their particular Churches, which may be likely to Produce any Imbroylments.
[Page 68]
Answer.
This is very Dishonourable, and also a very Unreasonable Incroachment upon the Officers and Government of the Churches.
It Divests the Officers of the free Exercise of that Office-Authority, which Gods Word and our
Plat-form places in them; Read
Platf. Chap. 10.
Sect. 8, 9. These are to feed and Rule the Churches, they are to receive the Accusations, and prepare them for the Churches hearing. This Section of the
Plat-form fixes both Process and Judicature in particular Pastors and Churches, without any Limitation? But the Proposal allows no Process to be Opened, till Letters of Lycence be obtained, from the Classes. But why may not all other Persons in Office be thus Fettered, as well as the Pastors of Churches? are these the only Studients of Wisdom and Righteousness, that are strangers to the nature of Actions, to the Rule, and the application of it? All other Officers, in Trust and Commission, who are wise and Loyal, execute the hardest Articles in their Imploy; and who may say to them, why do you so? Our Judges never stick to hang a man, so long as their Commission and the Law will bear them out, and they themselves are left, to be Interpreters of Both. And that this Proposal is a Sanctuary for Officers against a storm; alas! the most that we can make of it, is a Covering of Figg-Leaves, and may serve for a Harbour to Cowards and Fools but not for men of spirit and
[Page 69] Conduct. The Dream of an Imbroylment, can never Counter-Poize Duty; If men are Trusted with Duty, they must consult that, and not Events. If men are plac'd at Helm, to steer in all weather which Blows, they must not be afraid of the Waves, or a wet Coat.
It is certain, it was no Dimunition for
Timothy to carry St.
Paul's Cloak and Parchments from
Troas, 2
Tim. 4.13. Yet for Perticular Pastors in the Mannagement of Church-Government to do little more then to carry the Copies and Parchments of Associations about the Country, and hang up their Decrees on the Pillars of Churches, according to the Order of the Proposal, can never entitle them to such a Tribute of Love and Honour as the Scripture does assign them, as the purchase of their great Merits, 1.
Tim. 3.5. 1. Thess. 5.12, 13. such Bequestments as these from the fountain of Honour, must signifie more than some such poor low servile Business (no ways too high for
Jereboham's Priests to execute) as is laid out in the Proposal, but especially if they have but some one head man to Conduct and draw
up the Conclusion.
Sect.
That the Associated Pastors do carefully and lovingly treat each other with that Watchfulness which may be of Ʋniversal advantage.
Answer.
1
st. Whether Watchfulness is proper, or a Term applicable to Persons so Quallified, so Sacred, and in so
high a function as those who are here intended?
[Page 70]2
dly. Whether to
Institute Watchmen over Watchmen, be not the way to Distribute the Clergy into Inferiour and Superiour Degrees, and so
ad Infinitum &c. or at least till the Churches of this Country (for you must know this is one Proposal made for their Support) be Supported and well Ordered by Suffragons, Metropolitans, and other great Pillars of those Churches, where Clergy-men in higher Orbes, inspect those in the same Order, who are beneath them in trust and Dignity?
3
dly. But if you Intend honestly, only the Watch of one Brother over another, as is the Duty of all Christian People, one towards another, then
I cannot understand the sence of the Word, as
Applicable here, with the least good meaning or Syntax imaginable.
1
st. For tho' there is a Design of New Moddeling of men and bringing Clergy-men into another Form of Society, yet there is no Intent Divulged, that they shall Co-habit, Bed and Board together upon certain Charters, as the Fryars or Benedictines, in their Royal Monastaries. Indeed the Section might have been Ingrost with the first Canons of the
Dominicans or St.
Bennets Laws, when first entring upon their Monastick Life, but it no ways agrees with this Constitution.
2
dly. For, as for the Occasional meeting of men eminently sober and vertuous, what business can be supposed for a Watch, for about the space of 24. or 48. hours, in such Examples? Very bad men will hold out longer then so, in a
[Page 71] good behaviour under the awe of but some one venerable Person.
3
dly. And when these Eminent Persons, Members of the Association, are dispersed to their own proper Precincts, the Proposal surely does not intend they shall follw the Chargeable Example of Princes, who usually keep Spies in each others Courts, to inform themselves, how things are managed there; for its plain, the Charge and Expence in mannaging such a Watch as this, will Reduce all Clergy-men to this
Dilemma, That they must either vote up the Sallary, or vote down the Method. But then the thing it self is not fair; for it would seem as tho' they watched More for the halting then the help of each other. But as for the Proposal, a Riddle I found it, and a Riddle
I leave it.
Sect. And that if any Minister be accused to the Association where he belongs, of Scandal or Heresy, the matter shall be there Examined, and if the Associated Ministers find just occasion for it, they shall direct a Calling of the Council, by which such an Offender is to be proceeded against.
Answer.
I must Boldly and freely enquire, Whether this is an honest Answer to the Question propounded in the head of the Proposals? or whether in Reality this is the Supporting, Preserving and well Ordering the Interest of the Churches there Meant? If you, mean as you Speak, I am sure there is either some Dishonesty or some Misunderstanding between the Question and the Answer;
[Page 72] for it can't possibly be otherwise, unless the parts of speech are lately become a Chaos, and all words are not only of the doubtful Gender, but such unreasonable Epiceens, that not only both kinds, but both Contraries are signified in them; or thus, that to build, Plant, Repair, Pluck up, pull Down and Demolish, are all now become Convertible Terms; for take away these high Prerogatives from the Churches, and you take away their Being. These and such like Royalties, are their
Formalis Ratio, or the formal Cause (
per Quam Res est id quod est) by which they are, what they are; and this will be very evident, if we do but Read a short Lecture on the Churches Essence Anatomiz'd, or let their Essential and Constituent parts and Powers be Viewed in the History, and Philosophy of their own Beings, and we shall quickly discern your Mistake; for that end read
Plat-form. Chap. 5.
Sect. 2. Ordinary Church Power,
viz. of
Priviledge belongs to the Brother-hood, and may be Acted or exercised immediately by Themselves. And
More Directly to the Case in hand, Look into
Chap. 10.
Sect. 6. where there we read
‘If an Elder offend Incorrigibly, the Matter so Requiring, as the Church, had Power to call him to Office, so they have Power, according to Order (the Council of other Churches, where it may be had, directing thereto) to Remove him from his Office; and being now but a Member, in case he add Contumacy to his sin, the Church that had Power to receive him in to their Fellowship,
[Page 73] hath also the same Power to cast him out, that they have concerning any other Members.’
Now herein we find an Essential Article in the Government and being of these Churches,
That they have and hold such Jurisdiction over their own Members; That the Highest Tribunal Ecclesiastical on Earth, is There; and that their own Delinquent private Members, and Publick Officers are Tryable only there, and there they must Receive the Definitive Sentence, and abide the Execution of it.
And if so, then I shall make bold to Revive my Query again,
viz. Whether the Proposal is either Honourable, Civil or honest, thus to Tumble down at one Blow, this
High Seat of Authority? and to break open our Prison Doors, and Loose the Fetters of our great Offenders? and at the best, to take them out of our hands, and make their Mittimus to Forreign Pastors to do Justice upon them, and yet in the mean time, to Profess, they are doing us no other Injuries but only Repairing and Mending our Churches? Again, Whether this is fair, and work-man-like amongst honest men?
But to make a small Stop here, I must remind you, That this head is not to be passed over Slightly; for this is the
One Thing in the
Essence of our Churches, It is their Peculiar Infranchizement and Birth-Right, and we may not sell it with
Esau at a Cheap Market; If we Do, we undo our selves; for
Indeed you must know, here lies the
Marring or
Making of our Churches; here is laid up their
[Page 74] strength, and here hangs the Pick-Lock of their
Treasure; for by this Key stolen or wrinched out of their Hands, the
Churches of Christ in the
World, have been
Exposed and Plundred, for more then a Thousand Years, and many of them have nothing at this day left them, comparitively, but a poor, starved, shabbid, Implicit
Faith, and a dull, saturnal, blunt and blind Obedience, that a man would scarcely give a Groat for both of them. In a word, the Usurpations of the Pastors, since the great Revolt, having unshackled one another, and broke loose from the Restrictions they are justly subjected to, under the Churches Power of Priviledge, has utterly undone the Christian World, from
This Root of Bitterness, and Pride, from this
Seed sprung up, the
Man of Sin, as we have it in an
Anomulus Author, viz. the
Eletherians, pag. 4. In words to this purpose,
‘Then a little Preist had an Opportunity to Establish himself, Then there Appeared in the Temple of God that Antichrist, who calls himself the Vicar of Christ.’ And then the same Author going on to discover the Original of this
Monstrous Birth, he says thus, Antichrist was Conceived in, by, and from certain Affectations of Ecclesiastical Prehemincies. As tho' he should say, the first Spawn or Embryo of that Insolent
Hector, or Aspiring
Nimord, (who first Robbed the Laity of their Christian Liberties, and then Hunted down the Potentates of the World, and Brought them as a Rich spoil into his Habitation of Violence) took its Commencement from this
[Page 75] Principle,
viz. from the Clergies assuming to themselves this Ecclesiastical Pre-heminence,
viz. first their obtaining an Exemption from the Cognizance of the Churches, for their Crimes, and then in possessing themselves of the sole and absolute Jurisdiction (by a dispotick Government) over the Churches themselves.
But however things have been hitherto, I shall no longer uphold the Debate, by revising the Abuses that have been
done to the Christian Churches by an Ambitious Clergy, in the Ages past, which might more amply be discovered, by tracing the Foot-steps of the great Apostacy; But I shall end the whole Dispute on this head, by drawing up a Protest, and denying the Jurisdiction of the Court, erected and opened by the
Proposals, as being perfectly Disagreeing and Repugnant to our former Settlements and present Constitution.
SECT. IV. THat the Condidates of the Ministry undergo a due Tryal by some or other of the Association, concerning their Qualification for the Evangelical Ministry; And that no perticular Pastor or Congregation, Imploy any one in occasional Preaching, who has not been Recommended by a Testimonial under the hands of some Association.
[Page 76]
Answer.
To Monopolize (in the Great Articles of Trade) some very Rich Spice, and of such use for the good of Kingdoms, that they must needs perish without it, or be greatly Injured by excessive Sales, is accounted by good Common-Wealths-men intolerable; for such Men or Companies, so invested, can, with
Joseph in
Pharoahs Court, buy and Sell a Country at their own Prizes; even so, When these Churches have delivered up the Right in their Condidates to the Classes, they may then go a begging to their doors for their Ministers, and be contented to take what they are pleased to put off, and at their own lay.
Obj. But you may Object, that
Exomni Ligno, non fit Mercurius. Therefore the Judicious must Determine and set their Mark upon what is Merchantable, and throw by what is Refuse ware, or else there may be great Damage done for want of caution. And thus we come to the Plain point in hand, which is to be debated by Disputing this Question,
viz.
Quest.
Whether a Tryal by Associations is Preferrible to the Old Custom of the Churches, in promoting their Candidates for the Ministry to Publick Trust?
Answer.
In the Reply, I shall,
first, Consider our Candidates under Tryal; as to their Qualification, And (
secondly) Implead the Proposal on a Just Perjudice from the Corruption of the Clergy.
[Page 77]1
st. We may consider our Condidates under Tryal, as to their Qualifications, (1.) As to their humane Learning; and here we absolutely object against the Tryal of Associations, as Booteless, Useless and perilous both to them and to us.
1. To Them, it is no Diminution, or Trespass upon the Laws of Honour or Truth to affirm, That the
Settled Ministry in general (with some Reasonable Exception) is less expert in Grammer and Points of Phylosophy, then our learned Children are at the Degree of Junior Batchellors, and that from dis-use, Proved from all Experience,
Nam usus Promotos facit; and also for the sake of more divine studies, which Crowd out those first Ideas a great pace, according to that Observation, on a learned Memory,
Imago Imaginem Expellit, Aliis
(que) Alice Suceedunt, for as one Wave thrusts out another, so one Idea another. Therefore it is pity to Expose such venerable Persons to the hazard in this Service, least when they become Posers of others, they should be posed themselves. I do Remember an odd story when
I was at Colledge, it was Retained as a Reproach on a very Divine and worthy Person; tho' he was bred in
England a good Schollar, and also had been a School-master, and had taught the Grammer in his Young times, but yet having laid by in a great measure, the use of such things, for the sake of more valuable and Heavenly Speculations, being at the Solstice, and one of the Corporation, ventured in the Hall to propose this Question, to one of the Commoners,
‘
[Page 78]Quot Sunt Coela!’ To which the Lad with Sauciness enough, yet with a gramatical Niceness, only Answered,
Sed Audi.
Mascula Duntaxat Calos vacitabis et Argos.
That Prisians head will in likehood be kept bleeding from one Generation to another, by reason of some unlucky Strokes, if this Form be Established, and that to the great Detriment of those who strike the Blows.
2
dly. To
ƲS. Accedamical Learning we profess to be a very
Essential Accomplishment in the Gospel Ministry. It is introduced by the Ordinary Blessing of God upon Humane endeavours, to Supply the place of the Cloven Tongues, and those other Miraculous Gifts and Indowments of Mind Imprest upon Christs Ambassadors, whereby Fisher-men Commence (
per Saltem) Doctors of Divinity, and in an instant were stock'd with such Principles of Religon, Reason and Philosophy, that they were capable to dispute with
Athens it self, and Baffle the greatest Wits she could produce in defence and for the Advancement of Christs Kingdom, Act. 17.18
Thus it is very Reasonable that the Churches should be well assured of the Sufficiency of the Learning of those Persons, e're they presume on the Ministry; yet there is a fairer way in vew, fuller of Honour and Safety, than what the Proposal Directs to.
Our Accademy is the Store-house of Learning,
[Page 79] and this all Mankind will Assent to. When you have lost the Company of the Muses, there they are found in their Free-holds, where they hold the ballance of Honour amongst the Learned. This is the Place, if not of the Goddess
Minarva or
Apollo, yet the
Bethel or Temple of God himself; the God of Wisdom, where he, as cheif Architect, with his under-work-men, form Wise and Learned Men, and where you may have them wrought off at the first hand: Then certainly here we are to secure our Credulity and Confidence in this Affair; here we are to know whether they be or the Right Stamp,
Yea or
No.
That of all men living, the best and most Infallible Standard for the Philosophical Accomplishments of our Candidates, is the Judgment of the Honorable President and noble Fellows of our Famous Colledge; for this I am sure must needs stand for a verity, that the Judgment of a real Honest and skilfull Artificer (keeping close to his Shop) concerning the Nature and Qualities of an Edge-Tool which he hath wrought, and hammered on his own Anvil, out of its first Rude Matter, must certainly Excel him that hath been long from the Trade, that only takes it, turns the Edge slightly, or has but a Transient view of it! So that hence we may fairly infer, that (as to humane Learning)
Harvards Commendamus is most valuable and sufficient, and justly Supplants these Testimonials.
2. With respect to the more Evangelial Qualifications of the Gospel Ministry, we shall be ready
[Page 80] to honour the sufficiency of the Associates, yet must take liberty to Object a few things.
1. Suppose we, that the Tryal is made
per Concionem ad Clerum, by Preaching a Sermon in Audience of the Association, and I think this is the way proposed and generally agreed upon, as the Square or Rule most agreeable with
Gunter, to take the Dimensions, Length and Breath of our
Candidates by.
Reply 1. What can a Sermon do at deciding this Question? for that the most sensible and valuable, who are usually most Humble and tender, are lyable by this Stupendious Examination, to be baffled by their own Timerity, and quite dash'd out of countenance by their own fear. Alas! upon their first Entrance upon the Stage, to appear in so august and awful a Presence, this must needs dis-animate and put their thoughts into a Ruffle, as having in their afrighted minds the Resemblance of their going into the
Spanish Inquisition, rather then Dwelling amongst the Softer Measures of the Gospel?
Luther himself, (that unparallell'd Instance of Spirit and Magnanimity (as I Remember of his Life) hardly ever got over something of a Panick Fear attending him, through the course of his Ministry; and indeed, Men of the quickest senses are most liable to these Paroxisms. Then surely to put our
Tyros to this Test, which may daunt and dis-spirit the greatest Hero, is no ways Proportionable, especially seeing they may under the Inspection of Learned, honest and Judicious Men, both
[Page 81] Pastors and Churches, and thereby under Covert of more Private Invitations (with all their natural) creep into this noble Work, and keeping on, as their Courage and Strength will bear the Journey, may, Gradatim, attain a just and sufficient Probation, as our Learned youth have hitherto done.
Indeed, the Bold and Brazen, who can make a greater figure with half the stock, by many shircking Tricks, and dissembling Artifices, defended and supported with confidence and Delivery, may obtain the
Euge Juvenis, that they no ways deserve, as will be found, when they come to be Detected by a more Dilatory Search, or a more tedious
Analisis made of them. That, to conclude, as the Proverb is,
Ʋna Hirundo non facit Ver; one Swallow makes not the Spring; so in this Tryal one good or mean Sermon cannot Determine the man or
umpire his Case.
2. Suppose the Tryal must be made, and the Question Determined by
a Persons Conversation. And this is a very great Article in the State of all Serviceable men, and especially in the Ministry, 1
Tim. 4.12. 1
Pet. 5.3.
being Ensamples to the stock. Then Certainly a more Intimate Converse and Society, is a very
Invincible Plea. By the Laws and Costums of England, the Vicinage must be allowed, as affording the Most Competent Judges, when Persons Reputation lies at stake in Criminal Cases, because they are presumed to know some-what considerable of Persons and Cases of their own knowledge, and so
[Page 90] more capable of giving a Just Verdict. So in the Case, what do those Persons know of
[...] Learned Youth, who make up the Association? Our Candidates appear on a Certain day,
[...] blazing Stars once in an Age, and are gazed on▪ and then they vanish) Now what Judgment can be made on a mans Conversation by such a Transcient view? unless they must be handled in this Consistory, as Persons that have been bound to the Peace, and in open Court are to be delivered from their Recognizane by three Out-Cryes?
3. Suppose the whole stock of Ministerial Qualifications must be enquired into, and Judgment must pass by the direction of the Apostolick Law, 1.
Tim. 3.2.
Tit. 1·6.9.
viz. Let them be Blameless, Sober, apt to Teach, &c. and add what more you please, which the Scripture mentions, to fill up the Character of an Evengelical Minister, to compleat him in all his Gifts and Graces, either in his beginnings, or in his Riper State, and it is most apparent, that our particular Pastors and Churches, with the Learning, Experience, Grace, Wisdom and Discretion they are Owners of, can make a more upright, judicious and sollid Tryal, and give a better account of our Candidates from their frequent Converse with them, and their Occasional and Repeated Preaching amongst them, then the Wisest Association in the World can do, and it is easier Dissembling with the latter, than the former, unless the Association will take them home, and both Winter and Summer them.
[Page 83]Now then, considering that their Degrees, with the express Testimony of the Colledge (when Perticularly desired) are sufficient Testimonials of their Learning, and the Experience of their other good Gifts and Ministerial Qualifications, obtained by Converse, and their Occasional Preaching, has been the chief Test and Tryal for our Candidates; and by these Methods they have been approbated in order to Settlement in Office-Trust; and this has been the Custum of the Country and Churches for near four score Years. Wherefore, to conclude this Argument,
I make this Proclamation, That if any Person or persons disaffected with our old Settlements and Way in Churth-Conduct, will produce one Example led into the Publick Ministry by this Practice, which has justly offended him, and he will or can evince this to be the blameable Cause, we will then Surrender the Costum to your Mercy.
2
dly. I shall now Implead the Proposal on a Just Perjudice or Persumption of Corruption in the Clergy, Tho' we are in Charity for the present, yet in this way proposed, we have no assurance for the future against the Corruptness of such Societies; and let any Sober man observe and he will find abundance of poor Tools under the Mark of the Office, where these Measures, and such like, are in force and form. How oft is it Repeated, That poor Sordid Debauch't Wretches are put into
Holy Orders, when as they were fitter to be put in to the stocks or sent to
Br
[...]dwell
[Page 84] for
Mad-men, then to be sent with their Testimonials to work in Christs Vineyard? How long have the Indies, the Seas, the Provinces, and many other parts of the
Empire Groaned under this Damnable way of cheating God of his Glory and the World of Salvation?
Simony we know began almost as early as the Christian Church, and has prevailed amongst Clergy-men to a Prodigy. The Sacred things of Gods House have been a Trade and Merchandize, which has beggared the Churches and filled the Clergy in some Kingdoms with a Sacriligious and Exorbitant Pile of
WEALTH, and the World with a flood of Debauchees; and this Proposal puts us into the way to open the Shop windows again, and expose the same Wares to Sale upon a little Indulgence in our Country; for who can render a Reason that the same Opportunities, the same Temptations, the same Corruptions, the same Nature, and the same Power, would not produce the same effects? or that the same Climate, Seed, Ground, and manner of Culture, should not Yeild the same Grain at Harvest?
And what have we in pledge for our Security, more than the Fallacy and fickleness of Humane Nature, when the Power is delivered out of our hands?
Obj. You may object, That our Candidates, Thro' their own Ambition, and the Indulgence of perticular Pastors, Thurst themselves into the Work too Young, and this our way will Prescribe due Boundaries to them
[Page 85]
Answer. 1. In
General, St.
Paul solves a worse Case, than can be found (Pick whilst you are weary for an Example to quadrate with the objection, and render it forcible) amongst all our learned Youth, who have hitherto adventured upon the Ministry,
Phil. 1.18
What then! &c. as tho' he should say, What's that to you,
Sir? if Christ be Preached, all is well. And as to our Case, we may say, Despise not the day of small things, all men must have a beginning, and every Bird which is pretty well fleg'd must begin to fly. And ours are not of the Nest where
Icharus was hatch't, whose Feathers were only glewed on; but these belong to the Angelick Host, and their Wings grow out from their Essence; therefore you may allow them, with the Lark, now and then to dart heaven-ward, tho' the Shell or down be scarce off from their heads. And so we conclude with our Charitable and Divine Apostle,
What then! If Christ be Preached whether in
Pretence, or in
Truth, either by
Old or by
Young, yet therein we do rejoyce, yea, and will rejoyce, &c. to see our own
Nazarites ▪ so forward and well disposed, it shall add to our Joy, and no ways increase our Horrour, unless our Ambition should Surprize us with Fear, that such young starts should out-shine us.
2. In
Perticular, Where will you six the
Quando, and settle the Precise Aera, or Period of Time, for their Beginning?
1. There is no College or Statute Law yet Enacted, to decide this Question: Then of necessity
[Page 86] you must do homage to long and laudable Custom, as to a Superiour Authority, and honourable Ruler; and where that fixes the Time, you must submit; for Custom, when full of days, and of Noble Examples, becomes the
Common Law of a Nation; and is as soveraign and Pleadable, as the Dictates of a Parliamentary Power, at least, it shelters from Rebukes and Calumny: That for any Gentlemen to Affront, Talk-high, and Frown at the Early Zeal and beginnings of our Candidates, is but too much, in Imitation of the
Great Mogul of India, who after he hath Dined, orders his Trumpets to be blown, to signifie to the Princes of the Earth, that they have liberty now to go to Dinner; and when he hath finished his Formalities, if they please, they may vail their Royal Bonnets, and thank him for nothing; for where there is no Law, There is no Transgression.
2. Under the Gospel, we have no Precise time, tho' there was under the Law, when to begin and enter into the Ministry, the Gospel knows no Bar from Time, where Persons are other ways meetly qualified. Days and Qualifications, are divers things, and the latter are the Essentials of a Minister of Christ. It is not, how Old, but how Capable a Person is, which is the main point to be enquired after here. Therefore where (in some good measure) there is an honest Life, a Gracious Heart, an Orthodox Head, and a learned Tongue, There is no reason to send such Youths to
Jerico with
Davids messengers,
[Page 87] Tho' their Beards are not yet grown) to wait upon Time and Nature, for such an Accomplishment; for certainly those Recited are the Principal in the Argument. It is a story in the History of
Persia, that when the
Grecians sent some very young Noble-men upon an Embassage to that Court, the
Persians Reflected upon the
Grecian Republick for sending Beardless Boyes on so Grave a Message to so mighty a Monarch. To which the young
Grecians very smartly Answered,
That if state Policy did consist in Beards, then He-Goats would do for Embassadors, as well or better then Men: I must confess, I am some-what of their mind; and therefore I think it is not, How long men have lived, but how Wise they are Grown: GOD hath ordained Praise out of the Mouths of Babes.
Jeremiah pleads, he was a
Child, but that cannot null his Commission for the Ministry,
Jer. 1.6. St.
Paul guards the Ministry of young
Timothy, by Heavens Authority, to Defend him from Censure, for Audaciousness. What! for a Child to teach Old Men their Duty! Hold! says St.
Paul, 1
Tim. 4.12.
Let no man despise thy Youth. What! shall not our great Lord Illustrate his Grace and Power in what Examples he pleases? Has he not formed all the Powers of nature? and does he not furnish them with their Distinct Vertues?
&c.
Object. But you may say,
Days are full of Wisdom, and Youth of Ignorance
in the great Affairs of Salvation.
[Page 88]
Answ. Not always and universally so; as in the Examples just now Recited, and in many others that may be named, called in at the third and sixth hour,
Mat. 20. But however, if our Candidates must never begin till they are without Ignorance, or not till they have gained all Points (
ad unquem) in the vast studies of Divinity, then it may be said of all our Ministers, as Queen
Elizabeth was wont to say of Bishops, when she visited the Schools (
Study hard Children, study hard, for) Bishops are Old Men. So of Necessity, all our Ministers must be very Old Men. But I think that is more agreeable with our Necessity and state, both in Nature and Grace, which one of the Ancients was wont to say of himself,
viz. That whilst he studied to Teach other men, he Learn't himself. That Considering Theology, as well as Art, is a long study, and Life is very short, why may they not begin young? and also, considering that our Churches are no ways over Cluttered with Candidates, there is no need to serve them as Christ did the Money Changers, who with a Whip of small Cords, he drove them out of the Temple; and especially they having hitherto acquitted themselves in the main as men that need not be ashamed, and yet never any one of them, to this day, has been Represented as Learned or vertuous, or any way supported by these Testimonials.