[Page]
[Page]

THE CHURCH MEMBERSHIP OF CHILDREN, AND THEIR RIGHT TO BAPTISME

According to that holy and everlasting COVENANT of GOD, established between Himself, and the Faithfull and their Seed after them, in their Generations: Cleared up in a Letter, sent unto a worthy Friend of the AUTHOR, and many Yeares agoe written touching that subject;

By THOMAS SHEPARD, sometimes Pastor of the Church of Christ at Cambridg in New-England.

Published at the earnest request of many: for the Consolation and Encouragement, both of Parents and Children in the Lord.

Genesis. 17. 7.
And I will establish my Covenant between Me and thee and thy seed after thee in their Generations, for an everlasting Covenant, to be a GOD unto thee, and to thy seed after thee.
Mark 16. 16.
He that Believeth, and is Baptized, shall be saved.
Acts. 2. 39.
For the Promise is unto you, and to your Children, and to all that are [...] even as many as the Lord our God shall call.
1 Cor.7. 14.
Else were your Children unclean, but now are they Holy.

CAMBRIDG Printed by Samuel Green. 1663.

[Page]

CHEMNIT [...]US, that eminent light in the Church of God in those elaborate workes of his against the Papists ( Exam▪ part 2. can 14. de Baptisme) hath this memorable saying viz..

I T is not to be left free, to the choice of those who have been Baptized [...] In­fancy, when they come to be Adult, whether or no they will have [...] con­firmed, which was done in their Baptisme; as though the Covenant of grace, & Testament of pea [...], which is offered and sealed up to little Chil­dren in Baptisme, should the [...] first begin to be established, when the [...] of their will, when Adult, is added thereunto: for from [...] is wick a [...] ­tion, the Anabaptists imply have taken away, and Condemned Paedobap­tisme; but such Baptized little ones are to be admonished as they [...] what a Covenant of Grace, and Testament of peace it is, which [...] entred into with them in Baptisme: and by what promise of grat [...] [...] have likewise obliged themselves unto Obedience to God, with there [...] of the Devil; and they are seriously to be exhorted, that they render [...] to God for that wonderful great [...], that they abide in that Covenant of peace, and endeavour to fullfil that obligation, by mortifying sin, and [...] upon newness of life, and that they do this freely, and sincerely: [...] they shall, through unthankfullnes, depart from that Covenant, and [...] ­ment, that then they repent, and return to the Covenant, and subject them­selves again to that stipulated Obedience▪ But as for them that shall [...] o­therwise, the must severe comminations of the [...] and I [...] to be heap [...] up, and set before, them; unto which saith [...] communication is to be added, for these are the weapon, of [...] 2. Cor. 10.

[Page]

A PREFACE TO THE READER.

Christian Reader,

M ight I have had mine own choice, and desires granted, some other should have performed the task of a Preface to the following Trea­tise of my precious and much Honoured Father; but being put upon it, by [...] worthy friends, whom I knew not how to deny, I shall therefore humbly promise a word or two, in tenderness to the Truth, and out of un­ [...] love to these especially of Christ's poor sheep (how ever feeble, or di­seased) that either have been, or may be in danger of going astray from so great a Truth, as is the subject of the ensuing discourse: being sincere­ly desirous, that they may be restored, and from thence returned unto the Shepherd, and Bishop of our Soules, and may in nothing be made a prey to him, who is our great adversary, the Devil, who walketh about, seeking whom be may devour. For we should not be ignorant of his devices.

The enmity put by the Lord between the seed of the Woman and the seed of the Serpent, Gen. 3. 15. soon began to work, even in the infancy of the Church, in the family of our first Parents, as we see Gen. 4. [...]. by the Martyrdome of righteous Abel. No small portion of that fixed hatred, and hostility of the old Serpent, hath ever since been discovered against the young ones of Christs little flock. The multiplication of the Children of Israel, is the occasion why Pharaoh deals so wisely as we read; endeavouring first by the Midwives, secret­ly to destroy the male Children: and after that, more openly by an [...] to drown them in his Egyptian waters; for which what ever his pretence might be, alleadged Ex [...]. 1. 10. yet no doubt (as Calvin [...] place somewhat that way hint's) Satan had a design there­in, to cut of the name and posterity [...] Abraham (who is the Father [...] them that beleive, even of US all the Father of many nations, Rom. 4. [...], 16, 17.) and so to evacuate, and annihilate the promise of God, even that great promise of his everlasting Covenant, to be a God to him, and to his seed for ever, in their Generations. Hence also afterward we find this spite of the great [...] of the brethren, vented against these poor little ones, in the forbidding them Com­munion with the Church of God in that Worship which God had [Page] instituted, and which he had Commanded his People by the hand of Moses and [...], to observe, Ex [...]. 10 3. [...] that they may serve me, saith the Lord but hardhearted Pharaoh see [...] to scruple whether the young Children are a part of the Lord P [...] ­ple, as appears by his question [...] 8. ( But [...] Moses pleads for [...] young, as well as the old; for the Sons, and he Daughter, ve [...]se 9 but Pharaoh is of another apprehension, and resolution, verse 10. 11. he will let the men goe and serve the Lord, but not the little ones. Again Haman the Agag [...]te we find is not satisfied with the destruction of the old Generation of the Jewes, [...]ut the little children of the Church also are expresly mentioned, and designed to the same condemnation, and Massacre with their Fathers Es [...]. 3. 13.

And much more of the like nature might be alledged out of many records both ecclesiastical, and other, were it needfull: the satan call delusions of those [...] Ca [...]aphry [...]ians and [...] who were wont to mingle the Eucharist with the blood of an Infant of a year old, (of whom Austin speaks, Tom. 6. [...]) are not unknown. Not here to insist on that [...] of Herods Infanticide, Mat. 2. 16, 17. We need not so much wonder at Haz [...]ch cruelty against the Children of Israel in staying their young men with the sword, and dashing their Children, [...] dripping up their Wo­men with Child, 2 King. 8. 12. seing Satan hath many times prevail­ed with those who were Church-Members, and o [...] long standing in the house of God▪ even the pa [...]ents themselves, to [...] their Infants and little ones, which were the Lords Children and born unto the Lord, Ezek. 16, 2 [...], 21. &c. Such an [...] that great adversary of our comfort, and Salvation (seing [...] selfe shut out of the Kingdom of Heaven) bear against these [...] whom Christ hath taken in to himselfe, and concerning whom [...] Saviour profe [...]seth, that of such is the Kingdome of God, [...] 18. 16. So doth he envy to see them in the armes of Christ and blessed by him, and to have any room in his house, or so much as an extern [...] visible interest in the Covenant, with the initiatory seal and livery thereof. Baptisme being the seal to all Christianity, 'tis Sathan's policy therefore to strike at that, that in cashiering it, he may have [Page] at All; Hereunto tends his dealing with witches many times, (of which divers have spoken) in [...] them when they become first [...] solemnly to renounce the Trinity (into the name of [...] they have been Baptised) especially their salvation by Christ, and saith [...] discover­ed C [...]p 6 sec.1 pag. 9 [...]. in token thereof to disclaim their Baptisme.

An ill office and work then surely are they imployed in; whose way and indeavours, shall center in the accomplishing of that which Satan hath been so busily, and with such malignity, for so many ages undertaking, and no great thanks will such receive for that l [...]bou [...] from the Lord Jesus another day. If Christ was so much displeased, that his disciples rebuked these, who brought their children to him, Mark 10.14: And if the Apostle Peter received so severe a check, as wee read Mat. 16. 22, 23. for speaking that, which had a tendency to take the Lord Jesus off from laying down the price of [...]ption: how much more then will he be now displeased if [...] such rebuke and warning given any shall attempt to keep from him, and deprive him of, his Redeemed, whom he hath purchased by so dear a price [...]o many, I mean, of his purchased ones, as the number of the infants and children of Believers (dead, and alive, and to be born,) amount's unto? why may we not believe, that an exceeding great multitude of the S [...]eep that shall be [...] standing at the right hand of Jesus Christ in the day of Judgment, shall be a company of these Lambs? As to withhold from Christ so great a part of his purchase (the labour of [...]) must needs be no other them highly Antichristian; so to make good and recover the interest of Christ in such, and the Glory which he obtaines by them, according to the enlarged grant of the charter of his new Testament (the scope, and work of these few sheets) is a ser [...]ice pleasing unto Christ, who out of the mouthes of these [...]; and sucklings even perfecteth praise, Mat. 21. 15, 16. and so I trust will be acceptable to his People, who when as they must go down to the dust and cannot keep alive their own Soules, yet may behold their seed succeeding them in the service & worship of God, being accounted to the Lord for a generation▪ Psal. 22. 28, 29, 30, 31. ( [...]vide Rivet in locum) Schismatically to refuse to hold Ecclesi­asticall Communion with so great a part of the Church of Christ as▪ [Page] the children of believers are (in many places, the major part thereof) is a rigid and sinfull Separation, and gratifying the designe of the Pa­pists (the greatest Separatists in the world) as by & by may be further seen.

And indeed the Lord ( avenging the quarrel of his Covenant, wherin he hath alwayes been exceeding jealous) hath manifested not a little of his anger, and displeasure against those who have troubled these Baptismal waters of the Sanctuary; The awfull and tremendous pas­sages of Providence recorded in several histories, concerning the ori­ginal and progress of Anabaptisme: and relating to God's strange, judicial hand against so many of them that have been through-paced therin, in delivering them up to spiritual, judgments, to believe lies; and to fall, step by step, into almost all sorts of heresies, and to the com­mission of the most abhorred impieties, and loathsome wickednesses, and outrages, against the Commands both of the first and second Table, (as Luther, Bullinger, Calvin, Beza, and others generally and abundantly testifie) they are very observable, and not to be passed over slightly; and may make every honest & serious heart to trem­ble when ever he finds himselfe inclining to that path: to this pur­pose, and concerning Anabaptism in this our age (beside many o­ther Authors I might cite) read only Baxter's Plain Scripture proof of Infants Church-membership. Pag. 138, 139, 140-152. And as in the dawning of the reformation, begun by those Worthies of Christ in the last Centurie, Anabaptisme seem's to be the [...] horse whereby so great confusion did be fall that Israel, and was such Remora to that Glorions work then begun in Germanie, and other Neighbouring Countries; so now in the further progresse of that re­formation here in this our Israel, should Anabaptisme likewise (espe­cially accompanied with Donatisme it's wonded concubine) brood and become the instrument or medium of our miseries and confusions, possibly then experience (a slow, but many times a sure and severe instructer) may help some at length to see farther into the mystery of this iniquity, then now they do. For in truth it is not improbable, that the Man of [...] seeing he could not openly & at once ruine the [...]ef [...]rm­ed Churches in the dayes of those famous servants, of Christ before ex­prest, did attempt secretly, and gradually to do it this way; viz: by [Page] first sending forth his Emissaries among the Churches, who might fill them with the Smo [...]ke of Anabaptisme, that so he might the more securely pass to and fro, being undiscerned in such a fog: whence what mischief was wrought, and what an hindrance those turbulent Anabaptists were to the Kingdom of Jesus Christ in that age (for that was the first time of their swarming, as the most Judi­cious have observed) by vilifying, reproaching, and decrying the Mini­stry; crying up themselves as the most Godly, spirituall, and perfect▪ Judging the Old-Testament to be but as an Alma [...]ack out of date; denying Scripture-Consequences giving false interpretations of Scripture, especially by Allegories wresting the same to their own destruction; makeing and something schismes and factions in the Churches; denying the Magistrates [...] power in matters of Religion; making their own fana­tick spirit the supream judge unto all kind of disorder, &c: the writings of the Godly Learned in those times do abundantly even to amazement inform us. And indeed the great consent and harmony between the main tenets of the Anabaptists, and Papists in this point, gives not a little ground for holy jealousie, too sadly to suspect at what back­door it was that the Anabaptist first crept forth. And hence it is that in the controversies between the Protestants and the Papists, we shall generally, and abundantly find, the Papists denying the Ho [...] ­ness of the Infants of Beleivers before Baptisme; and how neer of kin this is to Anabaptisme the reader may easily guess: and in like man­ner denying that great truth (as is afterward shewed in this Treatise) viz. That the Covenant of God with Abraham under the Old-Testament, was the same for substance with what is now confirmed with us under the New-Testament, &c. which (tis known) the Anabaptists also general­ly assert: Let me therefore propound a few instances this way, wher­by we may see what Patrons of Anabaptisme the Papists are, in regard of those Principles (I mean) and radicall errours wherin the Papists and Anabaptists (although by divers of them, upon the account of a diverse interest) Symbolize and unite against the Orthodox, and speak herein, in a manner, thesame thing (distinguishing alwaies between the Opinion, and the person; and between some that are deceived, in other points Orthodox▪ and precious Christians; and others that are Deceivers.) The mainpillars of Anabaptisme being no better▪ then [Page] some of the Old rotten-studs and principles of P [...]pery, [...]cht at first from thence in all likely hood, and so inclining thitherward again▪ The D [...]alect of the Anabaptist is generally (and too much by some) under­stood, and therefore I forbear quotations out of their own writings▪ possibly some may not have so much taken notice of the like, from the Papist, and therefore I shall briefly manifest the same, by shewing where we shall find some of the chief of those Worthies that fought the Lords Ba [...]les against Antichrist, opposing, and confuting them both, therein: I will cite a few Particulars this way among many the like which might be produced from severall other eminent Au­thors, Holy, burning, and shining lights in the churches of Christ, who have been the Lords Witnesses against the [...] Spirituall E­gy [...]; and whose Testimonie in this matter concludes as strongly a­gainst the Anabaptists, having espoused those Antichristian notions so ne [...]rly to themselves.

1. ‘In those words of the Covenant ( I will be a God to thee and thy seed after thee) neither life eternall is promised nor remissi­on of sins, but onely a certain peculiar temporall protection. saith Bellarmine, (agreeing therein with the Anabaptist) against whom here­in we find Chamier pleading for us, Panstrat. tom. 4. Lib. 3 Cap. 3. Pa [...]ag. 9, 10. &c. and Rive [...]. on Gen. 17. 11. Again, we read (saith Bellarmine, the great Goliah of the Papists) that God promi­sed unto Abraham when he enjoyned him circumcision, earthly, mat­ters only, according to the letter: that is, the propagation of a posterity, and the Land of Palestine. read Ames opposing him: Belarm. Ene [...]v. Tom. 3. Lib. 1 Chap. 4. Thes. 9.’

2. Touching the perverse and Catabaptisticall intent and meaning of that expression of the Papists, viz. ‘That Spirituall promises des­cend to us not by carnall generation (as they call it the very Phrase of many Anabaptists, used in a way of derision of the Grace of God) but by Spirituall Regeneration &c.(they are the words of Bellarmine and o­the Papists, cited & confuted by Ames & others) read Ames his An­swer thereto, Bel. Ener. tom. 3. Lib. 2. cap. 1. Thes. 5. (consonant to the Judgment of the Orthodox) viz. we acknowledg indeed Spirituall re­generation to be necessary to the solid participation of the promises; but that that Regeneration is part of the Promises, and belongs in a sin­gular [Page] manner to the Children of Believers, the very form [...] of the Cove­nant manifestly declares. Seelikewise Chamier largely replying for us against Bellarmine, Stapleton, and others of the Papists▪ Pa [...] strat. tom.4. lib 5. cap. 10. parag. 24, 25, 26, 27, &c:

3. The Sacraments of the old Law ( or Testament saith Bellarmine had no absolute promise of Grace annexed, & the promises annexed to thos [...] old Sacraments were fulfilled, although men did not believe. Read Ames a­gainst him ibid. [...] 1. cap. 4. the. 5, 7. Again, the Papists [saith Chemnit­hold; that God, by the Sacraments of the old Testament, which had eve [...] the word of promise annexed, did ex [...]tbite & conferr no grace to Believeres which [saith he] is manifestly false; Circumcision alone [which, as he sheweth from Scripture, is called the Seal of the righteousness of Faith] demonstrateth as much. And thereupon he sheweth the reason why the Papists so much urge that difference between the Sacraments of the old & new Testament, viz. because they endeavour by any man­ner of meanes to defend and stablish the opinion they have of their opus operatum Chemnit [...]y Exam. par. 2. de Sacram▪sub canon. 2. What a forcible engine of the man of [...] this is, and of what vast con­cernment as to his interest, I need not here express, and what arrows of Anabaptisme, drawn out of this very quiver, have been shot against the Orthodox in this point, is known unto not a few.

Moreover, as to the comparison in Scripture made between the Sa­craments of the old and new Testament, that in 1 Cor. 10.1—4. (among several other Scriptures) is cited by Ames against Bellarmine where the Apostle speake's of our Fathers being Baptized in the Sea &c: thereby intimating our Sacraments to be the same for substance with theirs: or Sacramental signes and seales of one and the same spiritual grace, so that the Covenant-mercies, or promises of spiritual good are the same to us as to them: Bellarmine opposeth this [as doth the Anabaptist] The Fathers [saith he] are said to eat the same meat not because ours and theirs was the same, but because they themselves, all of them did eat the same: but that meat and drinke were not sacraments; they had no promise ane [...]ed &c: Bell ener [...]. tom. 3. l.1. c. 4. th.10. and Cham. panstrat tom.4. l. 3. c. 2.

4. The scripture no where call's Circumcision a seal. [saith Bellarmine to Rom, 4.] unless it be in this place, where Abraham is spoken of, which [Page] is a manifest argument that Circumcision was a seal unto Abraham alone Ames. ibid. c. 1. th. 12. By this weapon also fetcht out of the armory of Antichrist, hath the Anabaptist not a little gratifyed the common adver­sary.

5. The Papists generally assert, That the Baptisme of John was not the same for substance with the Baptisme of Christ, nor had the same efficacy, as the Baptisme of Christ hath. Which tenet see confuted by Cartwright on the new Testament, Mat. 3. 11. and by Ames Beller. enerv. t. 3. l.2. c.5. th.1, 2. &c. and Rivet Cathol. orthod. tractat, 3. qu. 2. and Chemnir. exam. part 2. de baptisme sub [...]on 1. and Chamier panstrat. t.4. l. 5. c. 12. still we see the harmony between the Papist and the Anabaptist. And hence we find likewise the Papist pleading for the rebaptizing of those who had received the Baptisme of John. Chamier ibid. cap. 13. paragr. 35. &c▪

6. The Papists assert, that Laicks [ as they call them, i. e. those that are not on Office in the Church] may in case administer Baptisme: yea that not onely men but women may do it. Read Ames his confutation thereof, Bell. enerv. tom. 3. l. 2. cap.2. and Rivet against Ba [...]ly the Jesuit. Cathol. orthod tractat. 3. qu. 7. add thereto Chamiers Panstr. tom. 4. 45. cap. 14. de legitimo Baptism [...] ministro▪ where, among other Passages, citing the thesis of Suarez the Jesuit, viz: that any body whosoever, that can speak, and wash, may be a sufficient Minister of Baptisme; whether he be man or woman; believer or unbeliever; bap­tised or not baptized, if so be he know how to wash, and utter the Word: with a due intention, [...] assertio (saith the Jesuit) est omnino certa, But saith Chamier in the name of the Orthodox, we teach the contrary, viz. that the right of conferring Baptisme belongs to those only who are publick Officers in the Church &c. which accordingly he there makes good against the Papists.

7. Ba [...]ly the Jesuite (whom Rivet encountereth) to the Question between the Orthodox and the Papists; viz. Whether the Infants of be­lievers are holy before Baptisme? he answereth roundly for them; NO. Rivet C [...]th Orthod. Tract. 3.9 3.

And touching that famous place controverted between our­selves and the [...], in regard of their wresting, and per­verting the sence of that Scripture, 1 Cor. 7. 14. [ [...] were your Chil­dren [Page] unclean, but now they are Holy] we may observe how they [...] in e [...]e steps of the Papists that have gone before them therein, [...]as they likewise do in that noted Scripture Col 2. 11, 12▪ not allowing Baptisme to answer Circumcision according to the mind and mean­ing of the Holy Ghost: wherein see Ames against them, Bel [...] [...] Tom. 3. [...]. Ca [...]. 4. Thes. 13.. and Rivet in Gen. 12 Exerc [...]: 88. Pag. 340. &c. Take a tast of that 1 Cor. 7. as followeth; Barly ( [...] Jesuit) before Cited, ibid: q [...]est. 3. laboureth thus to avoid the dint of that text, The Apostle ( saith he) either speaks of a civil Sancti­fication before men, that the Infants should not be ILLEGIT AM ATE or BASTARDS: or else of an Instrumental Sanctification, because that one shall procure the Salvation of the other, &c. the like we find of Bel­larmine's apprehention and Judgment of the sence of that Scripture; Such Children (saith he) are said to be not (unclean) that is, infamous and BASTARDS▪ but (holy) that is, LEGITIMATE, and free from civil ignomi [...]e: Ames. Ibid. I [...]b. 2. C. 1 Thes. 6. The Rhe­mists also very perniciously abuse this Scripture (and are not therein, without their Antipaedobaptisticall followers) Blessed Cartwright ex­cellently upon the place in his confutation of their annotations on the new-Testament defend's this cause of Christ against their Popish glosses: It is (saith he) one thing (oftentimes in the Scripture) to be Sanctified, and another to be holy: as for you, you [...] in both: for when it is said, the unbelieving party is Sanctified by the believing, it is not only meant, as you say, that the Marriage is an occasion of the Sancti­fication to the infidel party, but that the use of the infidel party, in Mar­riage company, is Sanctified, or made holy and lawfull unto the be­lieving party; as meat and drink is said to be Sanctified unto us by the word & Prayer, 1 Tim. 4. 5 and as your Interpretation here is short, so in the exposition of the Holiness of the Children, which are begot­ten in this Matrimony, it is utterly [...]alse: and first it is to be observed, that the Apostle speaking of the Children, doth not (as you do) apply one word of them to both saying that they are▪ Sanctified, but saith that they are holy; which is more then he had spoken before of the infidel par­ty for although our meat, and drink be Sanctified unto us, and that the use of them is holy to those which are holy, yet the meats, and drinks themselves are not holy: if therefore you were short in the interpretation [Page] of Sanctified, you fail much more, in giving the same exposition [...] [...]he holiness of the children; for if the holiness here spoken of, be not in the children when they are begotten, and born of the Parents, but come unto them afterward by Baptisme and Faith; there groweth no sufficient comfort unto the faithfull party to continue in marriage with the Infidel, considering that occasion of holiness might come otherwise then by marriage: For that which is able to uphold the faithfull in comfort, and strength to abide in marriage with the infidel, is the know­ledg that the Children begotten in that Marriage are in Covenant, and are Childrenof Gods favour, and grace, walked in Christs Bloud, and Sanctified by [...] Spirit: and if you well know what this Holyness of Children new-born is; the Apostle telleth you, Gal. 2. 15. That it is [ through the Covenant] to be a Jew by nature, or birth, and if you will yet further understand what this Holyness of Children is, the Apostle, in the same place telleth you; that it is, not to be Sinners by Nature as those which are born of the Heathen, for as much as their sins who are in Covenant, are by Christ not reckoned unto them. And this Doctrine of the Holyness of the Children which are born of the Faithfull, if you could not attain unto, [...] is so sensibly set forth unto you, that unless together with the knowledg of the Truth, you are also bereaved of your common sence, you cannot be ignorant of [...]t: for how can you but understand, that if the root be holy, the branch is holy, Rom. 11. 16. and if the first fruits be holy, the whole crop is holy All which privilidges of Children new-born, sometime being proper to the Jewes, are now our priviledges, as well as theirs; fit hence we are grown into one body with them, Ephes. 2. 15. and ( being Burges­ ses of the same Heavenly City that they are] must needs have the same infranchisement, and Prerogatives that they have: not that every one which is born under the Covenant is holy, but that they are so to be taken of the Church, until the contrary do manifestly appear, &c.

By the premises we may see therefore whence [even from that MOTHER of harlots] probably this Illegitimate birth, this antichristian sl [...]ud of Anabaptisme hath issued forth; yea and I also fear is like to be nursed, and maintained n it's course, until God hath [...] up those breasts, and rivers of spiritual Babylon, in the mean [Page] while, Calvins admonition touching Anabaptisme, may not be unsea­sonable, mer [...]ise debet nobis esle suspectum, quicquid a tale [...] produ­r [...]t. Op [...]scu [...] in Psychopannychia. Pag. 411. S. M.

There are some who though they graunt the Baptisme of some Children, yet utterly deny the continuance of that Covenant-mercy of God to their succeeding Generations, though the Church-society whereof they were Members be not dissolved, nor the surviving pos­terity so much as deserve to be, by the Discipline of Christ in his Church, excommunicated; This seems in truth to arise from their not acknowledging sufficiently, or not abiding by the true genuine grounds of the Baptisme of those whose right to Baptisme is acknow­ledged by them.

For the information (therefore) of the minds of the weak and stablishing their hearts in this Truth of God, according to the Scrip­tures, even in the Doctrine of Paedobaptisme (a Doctrine of so great concernment, and of so much comfort and incouragement, both to believing parents & their children, not in life only but in death; whence it is that they only can be preserved against sorrowing when they fall asleep, as others do, which have no hope) This ensuing Treatise is at the earnest request of many worthy freinds in the Author of it (of blessed memory) now published, wherein we may see both; 1. The Membership of the Children of Church-Members proved to be of Divine institution, and likewise 2. (among other things] The continuance of the Membership of those Children, in particular Churches, when they are grown up, even until they are excomunicated, unless there be [...]dissolution of the person by death, or of the Church-society: Instances hereof see in the preface to the act of the Synod held at Boston. 1682 Touch­ing, Baptism, & Consocia­tion of Churches. So that this latter is not a principle of Innovation, and Apostacy; but as it was the Judg­ment of the Author of this following Letter (as is therein to be seen and to manifest which was one speciall end of the Printing thereof) so was it the light which others have held forth, who in their time were Stars not of the smallest magnitude, whom we have here seen sometimes shining with him in Christs right hand, but are now set, and shining with that Sun of righteousness in another World.

That there is no cessation of the membership of a person in this or that particular Church (the Church whereof he is a member continu­ing in being, together with the person himself) unles it be by meanes [Page] of a Church-act intervening, is a truth of no small importance; And therefore as for that notion which doth obtain with some; That in particular Churches of Christ, walking in the order of the Gospel, there are such [...] become Ecclesiastically Felones de se, that is such Church-members wholly their scandalous sin, do become their own executioners Ecclesiastically, cutting themselves off from the Church, so as that they thereby become actually non-members, and that the Church hath no more power over them, either Ecclesiastically to admonish them, or Excommunicate them; this seem's unto me to be but an humane [...], and not of Divine institution, yea in truth [...] to the [...] of the Gospel. And therefore to apply it, (as to members in full communion, so) to these Children of the Church whom we now speak of, is not of God; as may appear by these reasons following.

1. Because it is unscriptural. In matters of Gods worship, a nega­tive argument is conclvsive; if that which is asserted; be not con­tained in the Scripture, expresly, or by due consequence therefrom, it is to be rejected. To the Law and to the Testimony.

[...] The Scriptures alledged by some, and thought to favour this noti­on of Felones de se, are only such as do but lay down before us the sinns of some Church-members, and do not speak of the [...] ( punishment or censure) as 'tis called, 2 Cor. 2.6. which in such case is to be inflicted, and therefore are not [...] only that which seem's to have most weight in it, and to which therefore I shall breif­ly reply, is that in Act. 8. 21. [...] part nor lot in this mat­ter▪ Answer. I would not say that this text, propounded with re­ference to the children of the Church that are not in full cōmunion, is not apposite, because the text speaks of a member in full commu­nion: though to say so much is accounted by some a sufficient an­swer to such Scripture arguments, as conclude against felones de se, from Church-members that are in full Cōmunion ( [...] Church­members) to such Church members as are not infull communion: But yet having gained this fort; that what is in Scripture spoken of a member in full communion, is applicable (as far [...] as meer mem­bership reacheth) to a member that is not in full cōmunion we may now the more easily proceed in the after discourse. To this Scripture (then, alledged for [...] dren of the Church not in full communion, by their [Page] sin, when adult, to become felones de se as above said, I answer;

1. That the objection from hence tend's as much to frustrate the Church act, or censure of, excommunication upon members infull communion: and makes that ordinance of Christ vain, & needless to the parents in full cōmmunion, as to these children. 2. These words of the Apostle Peter, were indeed a dreadfull admonition, and the Apostle being a Church Officer, did judg this sinner to deserve it for his simonie; so that he was not (grant­ing the cessation of his membership) felo de se. 3. By [this matter] spoken of in the text, seem's most properly to be meant ( not Church-membership, but) the power of giving the holy Ghost spoken of in the context, which power Simon Magus would have bought with money, and for which the Apostle rebukes him: and therefore his not having part or lot in that matter, is to be understood directly with relation to that Extraordinary power; the Apostle would have him know, that he should not share in such a power or priviledge as that was: 4. I would ask whether, if a Member of a church be discovered not to have his heart right in the sight of God, but to be in the Gall of bitterness and bond of Iniquity, stand convict of Simonie, and the wickedness be so grosly aggravated as this Scandal of Symon Magus was; I say whether the Church is not bound to bear witnes against such an offender by in­flicting some Church-Censure (properly so taken) upon him? if it be said [...]oe; then may it not be questioned, whether such a Church would not as well tolerate any other pollutions and defilements in it whatsoever? The wofull, fruit whereof who is there that doth [...] easily perceive: On the other side if it be said yea, that the Church is to Censure and Authoritatively to put away from among themselves such a wicked person by excommunication, I then demand (if this notion of felo dese be [...] and sound) how they can excom­municate one wh [...] is a non-Member before the Church can pass the sentence of excommunication against him? whether doth this Scrip­ture Act. 8.21. give the Church power over him by it's Discipline to censure him, who already (as the objection speak's] hath cut himself off from being a Church-Member? or whether the Church hath any part in him who hath no part or lot in them, or in these matters?

2. Scripture Example lead's us, to what is contrary to this Felonie spoken of: witness, under the old-Testament, Ishmael's being cast [Page] out, by Abraham who was the chief Officer in that family Church. So the incestuous person under the New-Testament is not felo de se though guilty of such a sin as was not so much as named▪ among the [...] 1 Cor. 5.1. but there is a Church-act intervening his sin and the cessation of his Memberly-Communion with that Ch [...] viz. a delivering him [ [...] such a one] unto [...]. Hence as the Church of Ephesus is commended for not bearing with them which are evill, Rev. 2. 2. so the Church of Thyatira is rebuked for suf­fering that woman Jezebel, verse. 20.

3. Because this notion of Felo de se takes away the use of a Mi­nisterial Judge in the Church, in case of the offences, and Scandals of this or that particular Member of the Church, to determine of the same. Supposing a person could ecclesiastically cut himself off from the Church by his very act of sin, there would then he no room left for a competent Judg to enquire into the crime whereof he is ac­cused, and to make particular application of the Rule to the case of the sinning brother, and pass sentence according to the true desert, and nature of the offence. That God hath ordained a ministe­rial judge is plain, M [...]tth. 18.17. [if he neglect to hear the Church] the Church is to be heard; the phrase of our Saviour Christ implies judicial superiority on the Churches part, and the inferiority and subjection of a part or member to that whole &c. but now this Fe­lonie denieth this order which Christ hath established. Though a person deserve excommunication perhaps, yet it must appear that he do deserve it; neither doth his wickedness for which he deserves ex­cōmunication, render him a non-Member till he be excommunicated; and hence in this case is very considerable what is asserted by that deservedly famous divine, Mr. Cotton, in his book intituled [the keyes of the kingdom of heaven] viz. Though the Jury have given up their judgment, Cap. 4. Pag. 14. and verdict, yet the Malefactor is not thereupon legally condemned, much less executed, but upon the sentence of the judge in like sort here [saith he] though the Brethren of the Church do with one accord give up their vote and judgment for the censure▪ of an offender, yet he is not thereby censured, till upon the Sentence of the Presbyterie.

[Page] 4. Because the binding and loosing, mentioned, Mar. 16. the opening and shutting of the doors of the Church by the [...] the Kingdom of Heaven, belong to the same power [...] subject: hence therefore as none may intrude himselfe, or can regularly be admitted or let into this or that particular Church without Church-act inter­vening, so none can be shut out, and deprived of that Membership therein (as abovesaid,) without an act of the same power interven­ing. Ej [...]sdem pocesta [...]s estligare, & solvere; cla [...]dere & [...] Mr. Cot­tons keyes cap. 7. pag. 45.

5. Taken from Mat. 18, 15, 16, 17, 18. Which command and in­stitution, leaves Churches under a solemn obligation of duty, that when this offending Brother or Church-Member deserveth excommunication that censure be duly inflicted on him; so as that thereby ( viz. the sen­tence or censure p [...]st against him, in case he will not hear the Church) he must be to the Church as an He then Man, and a Pu [...]lican. so that it is not a matter of indifferency, [to be observed or not to be observed] but after the steps taken [mentioned in verses 15, 16.] and the brother remain obstinate, 'tis Christ's Charge that then that publick process [verse 17.] be attended, whereby the offender be­come's ecclesiastically bound according to verse 18 Christ therefore requires a Church-act to intervene, as abovesaid, and so the offender is not felo de se.

6. Because a scandalous Member of a Church, by [...] of Christs Institution, Mat. 18. 17. is to be accounted not as an Heathen and Publican▪ but stil a Church-Brother if he will [...]ear the Church, this is clearly intimated in those words [...] neglect to hear the Church) run­ing conditionally which suppose, that if he will hear, he is not to be as an [...] Membership shall not cease notwithstanding the Scandalous sin Committed. Therefore by his wickedness and of­fence he is not [...] de se.

7. Because this felonie objected tend's to render that Ordinance of Church-Censure and Admonition laid down Mat. 18. 15. &c. vain and useless, for the [...], by his si [...] becomeing a non-Member and so no Church-Brother, hence let a private Member of the Church go to tell him his fault, in the s [...]nce of the text, which is in order to more solemn Church-proceeding and [...], in case he will not hear; [Page] or let the Church require him in the name of Christ to hear, in such a Church-way as is there spoken of; he may tell them that he is no Brother of the Church, for he hath by his offence [...]ut off himselfe, and therefore they have nothing to do with him: that that rule of Christ concernes only the Brother or the Church-Member, not one that is out of the Church, as he is, being felo de se, and therefore may say (according to 1 Cor. 5. 12.) what have you to do to Judge me that am without? If his sin be not yet great enough to render him felo de se, & he suspect that therefore the Church may have power over him & is going about to bind him on earth, so that (being thereupon also bound in heaven) he shall become bound from an orderly entrance in at the doores of other Sister-Churches, without Repentance first held forth to the acceptance of the Church which he offended; 'tis then but to commit another fault whereby he may be sure he shall be felo de se, and so he is beyond the Churches reach, and this frustrates Church-discipline, and renders vain that ordinance of Christ above mentioned.

8. To deny the intervening of this Church-act of Excommunication is to deny unto, and withold from a person deserving to be cast out of the Church, an ordinance, and meanes which may be for the saving of his soul, 1 Cor: 5. 4, 5. It is not enough to say that the felo de se makes himself no member; and so the Church is freed from his com­munion which would pollute it, as fully as if he were excōmunicated; for God's meanes are not empty or vain meanes, and to think to reach the full end, but not in Gods way, and by observing his meanes ordain­ed, is neither Christian wisdome, nor Gospel policy; yea to deny the ap­plication of this ordin [...]ce of excōmunication to the offending Brother is to deny a means for the Salvation of his Soule, and to deny a remedy for his Repentance, and the healing, and gaining of our Brother again.

9. Because the Holy Ghost command's the Church to Judge them that are within, 1 Cor. 5.12, Do you not judge them that are with­in? All that are within, are subject to Ecclesiasticall judicature, and therefore cannot by Scripture-Warrant be felones de se.

10. Because this notion of felones de se evacuate's that power gi­ven of Rebukeing before all, 1 Tim. 5. 20. which is to be done without partiality, (whether they be young, or old, rich or poor &c.) ver.21 [Page] and so likewise takes away that Authority given of reproving with all long-suffering, 3 Tim. 4. 2. leaves no room for obedience to that command (2 Thes. 3. 15.) of Admonishing the offender as a Brother &c. add thereto that this notion of the felo de se supposeth some disobedi­ence in a Church-member of an open scandalous nature against which God hath not provided the remedy of spiritual revenge in an ecclesi­asticall way, contrary to that 2 Cor. 10. 6▪ where the Apostle saith, we have in readiness to revenge all disobedience &c. that this is spoken of Church discipline is well cleared by that expression of worthy Mr. Cotton. viz. the Apostles revenge of Disobedience by way of reproofe in preaching doth not follow the Peoples Obedience, Keyes Cha. Pag. 15. but proceedeth whether the people obey it or no; it was therefore their revenge of disobedience by way of Censure in discipline &c.

11. The Notion of felo de se asserts the lawfulness of exclusion or shutting a Church-Member out of the kingdome of Heaven by none of the keyes of the Kingdome of Heaven, viz. by the sin of this felon, or gives the managing of these keyes, in a case which concernes the whole to act in (for such is the non-Communion of a Member with the Church into the hands solely of a private person: both which right reason doth plainly condemn.

12. Because were the sin of a Church-Member of as high and heinous a nature as [...], nay (which is more) though the Bro­ther of a Church should turn Heretick yet he is not immediately thereby a non-Member, or felo de se: he is not presently to be reject­ed: but a first and second Admonition must be applyed, and in case of incorrigibleness then follows the Ecclesiastical rejection spoken of, Tit. 3. 10. he must be rejected, but according to Gods Order, even the order of the Gospel: for all things are to be done in order, 1 Cor. 14. 40. so when the Apostle required the Corinthians to put a way from among themselves that wicked person, it is to be understood of putting such away, and avoiding such, and withdrawing themselves from such, and haveing no company with such &c. All in due season, and all according to the order of Christ, even according to that rule of de­livering such an one unto Sath [...] as is exprest, 1 Co [...]. 5 and suiting with that other command of Christ, Mat. 18. according as the nature of the offence is more or less heinous, proportionably is the [Page] [...] either in case the offence be at first [...] in case the offence be at first rise of [...] still we have no allowance from Scripture to entertain or admit of the Opinion of this Ecclesiastical [...].

Having thus punished [...] Discourse I shall now very briefly acquaint the Reader, in a word or two further, [...], the following cause, viz. that it was written by the Authors [...] three months before the time of his Dissolution. [...] sent to me who before the receipt thereof, was not so clear in the point of Infant-Baptisme but was hereby recovered, and stablished in the trut [...], and dyed in the same Faith as the letter did per­swade him, ( to use Mr. Fox his Phrase, in his Book of Martyrs, touch­ing that excellent letter which Philpot, that Glorious Martyr, a little be­fore his death also, wrote to a friend of his, that was then a Prisoner, upon this very subject of Infant-Baptisme who was thereby converted from the e [...]rour of his-way, Act mon. voi 3 Pag. 606—610. s m. as is there to be seen. A letter exceeding web worth the reading & serious perusally any, such especially as hesitate in this matter) The Reader may please further to mind, that this was not intended by the Reverend Author for the publick view; but was only a private Answer sent to a speciall friend, for his particular satisfaction, relating to some doubts mentioned in a letter of his to my Father concerning this subject: Had he purposed to have Written, and Printed off his thoughts to the World touching this article of Baptisme I question not but he would have been more polite and curious; and the expectations of those who knew him throughly satisfied therein.

I would not detain the Reader by any further Preface of mine: and therefore to con­clude; May this from one who is now in Heaven, unto such as may have too farr engag­ed against God's Covenant-meries toward his, and our poor Children, sent indeed-in-a special manner unto such▪ have a rich and effectual blessing from the Father of lights [...] mercies; a better effect upon their hearts, then that famous Letter had of Elijah the Prophet, upon Jeho [...]am to whom it was sent, 2 Chron. 21. 12. (written, 'tis thought by divers, before his Translation to Heaven, but concealed untill there was so fit a season for the presenting of it) May this Writing (I say) and in such a season also, have a better effect and fruit, even to bring them from the errour of their way, into the paths of Truth, and peace, and settle them, and others, more and more therein; That is the sincere desire of the [...] thereof, who [...]

Thine to serve thee in our Lord Jesus. Thomas Shepard.
[Page]

I. THOMAS SHEPARDIUS Anagr: Paradisus hos [...]em?

H E.! Paradisus alit Sanctis [...] hostem?
[...] Baptiz [...]m praecipit [...]se De [...]s?
[...], clem [...]ns, [...] u [...]nis,
[...] gr [...]mi [...] Ting [...]r ille suo?
[...] Ecclesia (mater) habe [...]i [...],
[...] Sanct [...]s vox ait esse De [...]?
[...] sic Shepardius [...]lim,
Non sic, [...] Scr [...]pt [...] rei [...]u [...]t, a [...]unt.
Non sic Doctores celebrat quos sanct [...]or, at [...]s,
Anglia quos celebrat Prisca, sim [...]lque nova.
His ut [...]nam San [...]s Deus ipse laboribus almam
E [...] superis, clemens, suppeditaret opem!
Qu [...] fine, Doctores non [...]ull [...], scripta [...]nec ulla,
Errores poss [...]nt carnificare malos.
Jus confirmabas puerorum, Christe, tuorum▪
A gre [...]to vellent cum▪ revocare [...];
Sa [...]git [...], Lactentesque [...] defendito ab [...]ste
Q [...]i vellet l [...]udes (—cunque) [...]perire [...].

Amen

II. THOMAS SHEPARD. Anagr: o a map's thresh'd.

LOe her's a map, where we may see
Well, thresh'd an heap of corn to be
By Thomas Shepard's happy hand.
Which from the chaffe pure wheat hath fan'd:
The wheat is the Church-members right.
(Both great and little ones) to witt
Unto the seal of Baptisme, all
That are within the Gospel call;
I mean Believers and their seed;
To whom the Lord hath Promised,
To be their God; and doth reveal
Their right to's Covenant and the seal:
On whom through Grace the Blessing came.
Of his dea [...] servant Abraham.
Be they or Jewes or Gentiles, now
No difference the Lord doth know,
The promise is to us and ours,
As large, or larger: and God pour' [...]
His Spirit now as much, or more
Then e're he did on them before.
And if that they were Circumcis'd:
Then we are now to be Baptiz'd:
Our Babes must now no less then theirs—
Be seal'd (as of his Kingdome heires)
Christ calleth them his little ones,
And as his darlings He them owne's,
Denouncing against them a woe,
That are despisers of them, who
Offend the least of them, and such
As do their interest in him grutch.
[Page] [...]ri [...]pus, with Gaius, Stephanas,
With others, were not all through Grace
Baptis'd that of their Houshold were?
And Children who will doubt were there?
Then let us not to them deny,
Nor seem as if we did envy▪
The priviledge which God from heaven
Hath through his grace and favour given.
Nor let us limit his good Spirit
In applycation of Christ's merrit:
Whose bloud was shed for them, as well
As those who them in age excell:
If such be taught of God, who dare
Deny, they his Disciples are?

III. THOMAS SHEPARD Anagr: More hath pass'd.

M Ore from this holy pen h [...]th pass'd
The Baptisme to defend
O [...] Infants that Church-members are
(If well you do attend)
Then any Anti-baptists can
with solidness confute.
I wish with all my heart that God
will grant these labours fruit,
As good or better then the paines
by other Godly taken.
That thereby all his precious Saints
he would please to awaken.
That none may any more oppose,
with Zeal preposterous,
The Truth which Gods most holy word
commendeth unto us:
That who were [...] convinced by
this holy Shepard's voice,
Yet in his Letter left behind
they may the more rejoyce.
He was a shining Light indeed,
few other [...]acn are left,
The Lord vouchsafe we be not by
our Sinns of them bereft.
And poure down of his Spirit more
upon his Sons surviving;
That will be more and more unto
Truth's lovers a reviving.

IIII. THOMAS SHEPARD Anagr: Arm'd as the Shop.

A Rm'd ( as the s [...]op of God's good word
Doth weapons unto him afford)
De [...]end's the right of little ones,
Whom God▪ in the Church-Covenant ownes
The [...] of this Church among,
To whom his Kingdome doth belong,
And there withall the Seal thereof,
Through his free Mercy, Grace, and Love,
Yet are there some which them forbid
(As once his weak Disciples did)
To come to Christ, and scruple make,
Whether therof they should partake?
But Christ was very angry for it,
As for such Zeale he did abhor it;
On come, said he, and welcom'd such,
With tokens of affection much:
As if that they and scarcely any
But such as they might chalenge any
Or part, or portion in his grace,
(So did his favour them embrace)
His Babes, his Lambs, his little creatures
He call's them. As for such defeatures,
Christ they defeat as well as them
Whom they presume so to contemn.
This holy Shepard is like David,
From Lyon's mouth, and B [...]re's who saved
That little Kid; whom God did crown
With great and singular renown:
And so this Shepard hath (no doubt)
A glorious crown his head about.
For all his labours, (and for this;)
In high and everlasting bliss.
And as the Lord doth honour him
(For Christ his sake) so his esteem
Both is, and ought to be most rare,
[...]Mongst them who Christ his followers are,
And oh how should we bless his Name
That on his▪ Son he powr's the same
Good Spirit that was in the Father
Or doubles it upon him rather:
LORD these Epistles do thou bless!
And as thy Truth they do confess
So make them precious in the eyes
Of all that do thy Gospel prize.

Amen

[Page 1]

THE CHURCH-MEMBERSHIP OF CHILDREN CLEARED UP IN A LETTER IN ANSWER To the Doubts of a Friend.

W Hen we say, That Children are Members by their Pa­rents Covenant, I would premise three things for Ex­plication.

1. That Children of Godly Parents come to the fruition of their Membership by their Parents Covenant, but that which give's them their right, and interest in this Membership is Gods Covenant, whereby he engageth himselfe equally to be a God to them, and to their Seed. This I suppose is clear.

2. That according to the double Seed, viz. 1. Elect Seed. 2. Church-Seed; So there is a double Covenant, 1. External and out­ward: 2. Internall and inward. And because the Covenant makes the Church, hence there is an inward, and outward Membership, and Church estate: there is an outward Jew, & an inward Jew, Rom. 2. 28, 29. All are not Israel ( i. e. the elect Seed) that are of Israel ( i. e. the Church-Seed or in outward Covenant) to whom the Apostle saith belong's the Adoption, the Covenants, and the promises, that is, the ex­ternall Adoption whereby God account's them his Children, or the Children of his house, an family, the Children of the Church; and accordingly have the promises belonging to them in respect of outward dispensation although they be not Children by internall Adoption, to whom belongs the promises by effectuall and speciall communication of saving Grace: It is clearer then the day, that ma­ny who are inwardly, or in respect of inward Covenant, the Children [Page 2] of the Devil, are outwardly, or in respect of outward Covenant, the Children of God, Isay. 1. 2. I have brought up Children, and yet Re­bellious; and in the next verse they are called [ my People] ( i. e. by outward Covenant) and yet worse then the Ox, or Asse: Deut. 32. 19, 20. they are called Sons, and yet provokeing God to revengefull Wrath; and Children, and yet without Faith. And look, as some may be externally Dogs, and yet internally Believers: (as the woman of Cānaan, whom, in respect of outward Covenant, Christ calls a Dog: and the Jewes, who yet rejected him Children Mat. 15. 26) so many may be externally Children, in respect of external Covenant, and yet internally Dogs, and evil men, and we see that the purest Churches of Christ are called Saints, and faithful, & Children of God and yet many among them Hypocrites, and unbelievers; because they that in respect of Church estate, and outward Covenant, and profession, are outwardly, or federally Saints; are many times in­wardly, and really un [...]ound: Hence therefore it is, that when we say, that Children are in Covenant, and so Church-Members the mean­ing is, not that they are alwaies in inward Covenant, and inward Church-Members, who enjoy the inward, and saveing benefits of the Covenant, but that they are in external, and outward Covenant, and therefore outwardly Church Members, to whom belongs some outward priviledges of the Covenant for their inward and eternall good.

These things being clear, I the rather make mention of them, to undermine d [...]vers usual objections against the Membership, and Co­venant-Interest of Children; as, that they have no saving Grace ma­ny times; and that they make no actuall profession of any grace; and that many of them degenerate, and prove corrupt, and wicked &c. for suppose all these, yet God may take them into outward Co­venant (which is sufficient to make them the Church-Seed or Mem­bers of the Church) although he doth not receive them into inward Covenant, in bestowing upon them saving Grace, or Power to profess it, nay though they degenerate, and grow very corrupt after­ward.

3. Because you may question what this outward Covenant i [...], to which the seales are annexed; and under which we shall prove, [Page 3] Children are comprehended; and because the Knowledg of it is ex­ceeding usefull and very pleasant, I shall therefore [...] a short taste of it, as a light to our after-discourse, especially as it is considered in the largest extent of it. This outward covenant therefore consists chiefly of these three branches, or speciall promises:

1. The Lord engageth himselfe to them, that they shall be called by his Name, or his Name shall be called upon them, as 'tis Isay. 63. 19. They shall be called the Sons of God, Hos. 1. 10. and the People of God, Deut. 29. 12. 13. Thou becamest mine, Ezek. 16. 8. They may not be his Sons, and People really, and savingly, but God will Ho­nour them outwardly (at least) with this name, and priviledg: they shall bear his name, to be called so, and consequently to be accoun­ted so by others, and to be reckoned as of the number of his visible Church, and People; just as one that Adopts a young Son, he tel's the Father if he carry it well toward him when he is grown up to years, he shall possess the inheritance it selfe, but yet in the mean while he shall have this favour to be called his son, and be of his fami­ly, and houshold, and so be reckoned among the number of his Sons: see Rom. 9. 4.

2. The Lord promiseth that they shall, above all others in the World, have the meanes of doing them Good, and of conveying of the speciall Be­nefits of the Covenant; Nay they shall be set apart above all People in the World, to enjoy these speciall benefits of Remission of Sins, power against sin, eternal life, &c. and shall certainly have these, by these meanes, unless they refuse them: this is evident from these, and such like Scriptures and examples; what priviledge hath the Jew (saith the Apostle, Rom. 3. 1. and what advantage by Circumcision, if by nature under wrath, and sin▪ for upon that ground the Apostle make's the question) he Answers 'tis much every way, but chiefly because to them were committed the Oracles of God: i. e. the Word, promises, Covenant: which are the ordinary meanes of saving grace▪ and eternall good: others hear the word, but these in outward Covenant enjoy it by Covenant, and promise; and hence these in the first place, and principally, are sought after by these meanes; and therefore Christ forbids his Disci­ples at first to go preach in the way of the Gentiles (persons out of Covenant) but to the lost sheep of the house of Israel, Mat. 10. 6. and [Page 4] himselfe tells the Woman of Canaan, that he came not but to the lost sheep of [...] house of Israel, Mat. 15. 24. And although he bid's his disciples go preach to all nations, yet Acts 3. 26. it's said unto you First hath he sent Christ, because you are children of the pro­mise and Covenant, verse 25: Repent therefore, and be conversed, verse 19. Do not resist, or refuse Christ, for he hath First sent Christ to you to bless you, and turn you from your iniquities; and the promise is full and fair, Rom. 11. 23. If they abide not in unbeliefe, ( i. e. in refusing grace, and Christ when offered) they shall be graffed in, for God is able to do it, and will do it: and the reason why the Lord gave his people up to their own counsells; it was, because My people would none of me, after all the meanes God used for their good, Psal. 81. 11, 12, 13. And Deut. 7. 6. The Lord hath chosen you, above all people on the earth, to be a special people to himselfe, and thou art an holy people unto the Lord: How a holy people? by inward holiness? no verily, for many of them were inwardly unholy, both Parents and children, but thou art holy, i. e. thou art externally sanctified, and set apart by special meanes of holiness, to be a special people unto God. And there­fore Isay 5. 7. the men of Judah are called Gods pleasant plant: i. e. planted into the root and fatness of the Church, and therefore had all meanes used for their further special good, verse 4. What could bee done to my vineyard, that hath not been done? And hence it is, that though the word may come to heathens as well as Church-mem­bers, yet it comes not to them by way of Covenant, as it doth to Church-members; nor have they any promise of mercy aforehand, as Church-members have; nor is it chiefly belonging to such, but unto the children of the Covenant & the promise, as hath been said. And hence also it follow's that God never cutt's off the seed of his Servants from the special benefits of the Covenant, untill they have had the meanes thereunto, and they have positively rejected those meanes: and hence the Jewes (who are made the Pattern of what God will do toward all Gentile-churches, Rom. II.) were never cast off till by positive unbelief they provoked the Lord to break them off, by rejecting and refusing the meanes of their eternal peace

3. The Lord promiseth, that the seed of his people (indefinitely con­sidered) shall have this heart ( viz: which would refuse special grace, and mercy) taken away, as well as meanes used for that end: this is evi­dent [Page 5] from Deut. 30. 6. The Lord thy God r [...]ill Circumcise thy heart and the heart of thy seed, to love the Lord: he will cut off the uncircumci­sion, and sin, and resistance of the heart against God; he will take away the stony heart: not indeed from all, in outward Covenant par­ticularly; but from these indefinitely; so that there is no promise to do this for any out of the visible Church, (though God of his Sove­raignty, and free mercy somtimes doth so) but the pr [...]mise of this belongs indefinitely to those of his Church, among whom usually, and ordinarily he worke's this great work, leaving him to his own freeness of secret mercy, to work thus on whom he will, and when he will: in the mean while no man can exclude himself, or any others within this Covenant from hope of this mercy, and grace, but may with comfort look and pray for it; for this is Gods Covenant that the Redeemer shall come out of S [...]on, and turn away ungodlyness from Jacob, Rom. 11. 26, 27. for the Covenant of God doth not only run thus; If thou believe and receive grace thou shalt have it; but thus also, I will Circumcise your heart, I will take away the stony heart, I will turn away ungodliness from you, I will enable to believe: And hence these three things follow from these things thus opened.

1. That as the Covenant run's not only thus, viz. If thou believ­est thou shalt be saved, but also I will enable to believe; So a mans entrance into Covenant is not only by actual and personal professi­on of Faith [as some say] because God's Covenant run's a peg high­er, viz: to make and enable some to believe, and so to make that profession.

2. That the very outward Covenant is not meerly conditional, but there is something absolute in it: and hence it follow's, that it is a great mistake of some who think that Circumcision, and Baptism, seal only conditionally [the outward Covenant being [say they] meerly conditionall] for those three things mentioned in the outward Covenant you see are in some respect absolute, and if the Covenant was only conditionall, then the Lord was no more in Covenant with Church-Members, than with pagans, and infidels, for it may be propounded conditionally to all such, that if they believe, they shall be saved, but assuredly God's grace is a little more extensive to the one, then to the other.

[Page 6] 3 Hence you may see what Circumcision once did, and Baptisme now seal's unto, even to Infants the seal is to confirm the Covenant: the Covenant is, that God (outwardly at least) owne's them, and rec­kon's them among his people, and Children, within his visible Church and Kingdome, and that here upon he will prune, and cutt, and dresse, and water them, and improve the means of their eternal good upon them, which good they shall have, unless they refuse in resisting the means; nay that he will take away this refuseing heart from among them indefinitely, so that though every one cannot assure himself, that he will do it particularly for this or that person, yet every one, through this promise, may hope, and pray for the communication of this grace, and so feel it in time.

These things thus premised, to clear up the ensuing discourse, I shall now do two things. 1. Leave a few grounds and reasons to prove, that Children are in Church-Covenant, and so enjoy Church-Membership by their parents. 2. I shall then Answer your scruples.

To the first; The truth of it is manifest, by clearing up this propo­sition; Argum: 1. viz: That one and the same Covenant which was made to Abraham in the old Testament is for substance the same with that in the New; and this under the new Testament, the very same with that of Abraham's under the old.

I say for Substance the same, for it is acknowledged that there was somthing proper and personal in Abraham's Covenāt, as to be a Father of many Nations, but this was not of the Substance of the Covenant, which belong's to all the Covenanters, and unto which the S [...]l of Circumcision was set: for all Abraham's seed, neither in those, nor these dayes, are the fathers of many nations, nor did Circumcision seal it.

Again it is confessed, that the external administrations of this one & the same covenant, are diverse; but still the Covenant for substance is the same: For that old covenant was dispensed with other external signes, sacrifices, types, prophesies, then this under the new. There was something Typical in Abraham's covenāt concerning Canaan a type of heaven but yet the same Covenant remaine's now with a more naked manner of dispensation, or promise of heaven▪ And hence it follow's, that if it may appear, that the Covenant it self is one and the same, now, as then; then, as now; then it will undeniably [Page 7] follow, that if the New Covenant under the Gospel be not a carnal Covenant, no more was that: if the new-Covenant be not proper to Abraham's natural seed, no more was that which was made with A­braham: if the substance of that Covenant was, I will be a God to thee and the seed, then this very Covenant remaine's still under the Gospel, it being one and the same with that; if by vertue of that Co­venant, the Children were made Members of the Church; and hence had a Church priviledge, and seal administred; then the same Cove­nant remaining the same, and in the same force, and benefit, our Children also are taken into the like Membership. It remaine's ther­fore to prove that which all our Divines have long since made good against the Papists, that the Covenant then, and now, is for substance one and the same; or that the Coven [...]t made with Abraham was a Gospel-Covenant, and this Gospel-Covenant the same that was made with Abraham.

1. The Covenant made with Abraham is renewed in the Gospel, as to the main thing in it, viz. I will be their God, and they shall be my people, Heb. 8. 10. Jer. 31. 33 and though the seed be not exprest, yet its understood, as 'tis Gen. 17. 8. & if need be shall be proved hereafter.

2. Because Abraham's Covenant is of Gospel & eternal priviledges. Not proper therefore to him, and his fleshly posterity. For righteous­ness by Faith was sealed up by Circumcision Rom. 4. 11. which is a Gospel priviledge, and is the ground of all other priviledges, and yet in Gen 17 7. there is no expression of this righteousness▪ by Faith, but it is understood therefore in this, I will be their God; So the promise of eternal life, and resurrection therunto is wrapt up in this, I am the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob.

3. Because there was never any Covenant, but it was either of Grace, or workes: that of workes on mount Sinai, that of Grace which was made with Abraham: and hence Gal. 3 17. The Covenant which was confirmed afore by Christ, [...] Law 430 years after cannot dis [...]null: and what was that Covenant before? surely it was the Covenant of Gr [...], becau [...] it was confirmed by Christ: and what was this Cove­nant confirmed by [...], but the Covenant made with Abraham? for of this the Apostle speakes, verses 14, 16. And he cal's it express­ly by the Name of Gospel, or the Gospel Covenant; verse 8, 9.

[Page 8] 4. Because when God reneweth his promise and Covenant made with Abraham, with his people at the plaines of Moab, Deut. 30. 6. it run's in these words, viz: I will Circumcise thy heart, and the heart of thy seed, now this is a Gospel priviledg [...], and a Gospel-Covenant: as ap­peares by comparing this text with Rom. 10. 8. wherin the right [...]o [...]s­ness of faith, or the Gospel, is brought in speaking the words of this Covenant, saying the [...] in thy heart & mouth, Deut. 30. 11, 12, 13, 14. Now if that place, Gen. 17. 7. should be said to be obscure concerning the promise [I will be a God to thy seed] yet here in this place God speak's plainly, which by comparing the scrip­tures is a Gospel promise, and of a Gospel priviledge and therefore to be preach't by Ministers of the Gospel, and to be believed by the professors of it.

5. Because this promise [I will be a God to thee and thy seed] doth not belong to Abraham & his seed as after the [...], or as lineally descend­ed of Abraham: but as believers, and this is most evident Rom. 11. wherein 'tis said of the Jews, 1. That they were broken off (made no people no Church▪ by unbeliefe, verse 20. [...] 2. That by Faith they shall be graffed in again, verse 23. If therefore they were bro­ken off the Church by [...], then they stood as members of the Church by [...]: and if by faith they should be graffed in, then they stood by faith at first: Against is said in this Rom 11. 28. that they are love [...] for the [...], surely not as [...] fathers, but as spi­ritual by faith: and hence [...] 9. 8. it is expressly said, that God found Abraham faith, [...] before [...], and made a Covenant with him.

Again if the posterity of Abraham were Members upon this ground only or chiefly, viz. because they were [...] of [...], then [...] Rom. 11. 20 could never have been cast off from being Members of the Church, because they were alway the natural off-spring & posterity of Abraham. Hence therefore it fol­low's that if they were ingraffed in the Church as [...] (the Fa­thers as actually believing the Children as [...] apart by [...] of God to be [...]ade to believe and in their Parents Faith accounted be­lievers) then all believers at this day have the same priviledge and the Covenant then being made only in respect of Faith, must needs be Gospel Covenant, the same with God's Covenant at this day. And [Page 9] hence also it follow's that if they were Members as Believers, then not as Members of that nation. They were not therefore members of the Church, because they were descended of Abraham, and were in a national Church, and were by generation Jews. Circumcision was a Seal of Righteousness by Faith, Rom. 4. 11. therefore they were sealed as believers.

Thus much for the first argument, wherein I have been the larger, because much light is let in by it, to answer divers mistakes. I shall name the rest with morer brevity.

Argum: 2. If it was the curse of Gentiles, to be strangers to the Cove­nants of promise (made with the Jews) before they became the Churches of God; then by being Churches, this Curse is removed; and hence Ephe. 2. 12, 13. The Apostle saith they were strangers to the Covenant, and Common-wealth of Israel, but are not so now. If you say that the Ephesians were in Covenant, but not their seed, and so they were not strangers? I Answer that the Apostle doth not set out their cursed estate meerly because they were without any Covenant, but because they were strangers to that Covenant of promise which the Israelites had; for if their children had it not, they were then as without Covenant▪ so without God, and without hope, as Pagans are, which is notoriously cross to the current of all Scripture, as may afterward appear.

Argum: 3. The Apostle expresly saith [ Your children are holy] 1 Cor. 7 14. and if severally holy, then of the Church, [for reall holy­ness cannot be here meant] and in the Covenant of its even as 'tis said Deut. 7. 6 thou art an Holy people unto the Lord thy God: few of which number were really and savingly holy, but they were all so fede­rally, or by Covenant, and so became Gods special Church or people.

If you say, That this holiness is meant of matrimonial holiness, viz. that your children are not [...]ast [...]rds, but legitimate: The answer is easy; for upon this interpretation the Apostle's Answer should be false; for t [...]en if one of the parents had not been a Believer, and so by his Believing Sanct [...]f [...]ed his unbelieving W [...]fe, their Children must have been Bastards, whereas you know that their Children had not been in that sence unclean or ill [...]g [...]ti [...]ate, although neither of them were Believers: for the Apostle's dispute is plain, viz. that if the [Page 10] Believing Husband did not Sanctify his unbelieving Wife, then were your Children unclean, i. e. say you Bastards, but it's evident that Chil­dren may be, in this sense, clean, and yet no Faith in either Parent to Sanctify one another to their particular use: unless you will say, that all Children of heathens are Bastards, because neither of the pa­rents Believe.

Argum. 4. Rom. 11. 17. The Jews are cut off from the fatness of the Olive tree, and the Gentiles put in, or ingraffea in their room: Now this Ingraffing is not into Christ by saving faith, for it is impossible that such should ever be broken off, who are once in; it must there­fore be meant of their ingraffing into the external state of the visible Church, and the fatness and priviledges thereof; of which Church Christ is the external and political head, into whom (in this respect) they are ingraffed by external visible Faith and Covenant. Hence thus I reason; That if the Iews and their Children were ingraffed members of the Church, then the Gentile Churches ingraffed into the same state, and comming in their room, are, together with their Children, members of the Church: when the Jews hereafter shall be called, they shall be ingraffed in as they were before; them and their seed, verse 23. In the mean while, the Apostle put's no differ­ence between the present ingraffing of the Gentiles now, and of theirs past, or to come, and therfore they, and their seed are ingraffed Members now.

Argum: 5. Because there is the same inward cause, moving God to take in the Children of believing Church-members into the Church, and Covenant now, to be of the number of his people, as there was for taking the Iews and their children: for the only cause why the Lord took in the Jews and their Children thus, was his Love, and free grace, and mercy De [...]. 4. 37. because he Loved thy fathers, ther [...]fore [...] [...]hose their seed, which choosing is not by eternal Election or choosing to glory; for many of their seed never came to Glory; but unto this priviledg to be his people above all others, in outward Covenant with him; which is exceeding great Love, if you Remember what hath been laid of the branches of this outward Covenant▪ and visible Church estate. And hence [...]. 10. 15. [...], had a delight in thy fa­thers, hence he chose then seed above all people, as at that day, viz. to [Page 11] be his people: so that I do from hence fully believe, that either God's love is in these dayes of his Gospel less unto his people, and servants, then in the dayes of the old Testament, or if it be as great, that then the same Love respects the seed of his people now, as then it did. And therefore, if then, because he loved them, he chose their seed, to be of his Church; so in these dayes, because he loveth us, he chooseth our seed, to be of his Church also.

Argum: 6. Because our Saviour speak's plainely of all Children who are brought to him, that of such is the Kingdom of heaven: and none are ordinarily heires of the Kingdom of Glory, but such as are of God's visible Church, and Kingdom her [...]. The objections against this place; I think not worth confuting, because I hope enough is said to clear up this first particular, to prove the children of con­federate believers to be in Covenant, and Church-members.

I now proceed to the second thing, viz: to answer your objectiōs

Object: 1. If Children (say you) be members as it was in Abra­ham's Covenant, then wives and servants, and all the houshold are to be taken in; for so it was, Gen. 17. & Gen. 35. 2: 3. and then what Church­es shall we have? but such as you fear, God will be weary of & angry with.

Answ. Churches at first (by your own confession) were in fa­milies, where therfore God's grace did the more abound, by how much the less it did abound abroad: And hence Abraham's family and houshold was a Church of God; but yet consider withall▪ that all were not of this Family-church, meerly because they were of the family or houshold, but because they were Godly, or the children of such as were godly in the family; for Abraham's servants and hous­hold, were such as he could and did Command to keep the way of the Lord, and so were obedient to God in him▪ Gen. 18. 19. and we see they did obey, and did receive that new, strange, & painfull signe of Circumcision: about the nature and use of which, no doubt he first instructed them, and in the place you mention, Gen. 35 4. they gave to [...] all [...], & [...], to worship God more pu [...]ly And it's evident, Ex [...]. 12. 4 [...] that every one in the family had not to do with the [...] of the Church, & therefore [...]ow not of the Church though of the finaly: for [...] was not to eat of the [...] was every one who was bought with money to eat of [...]t [Page 12] untill they were Circumcised, ver. 44. nor were any such to be circum­cised, until they were willing & desireous to eat the P [...]sseover, & that unto the Lord; then indeed they, & theirs were first to be Circumcised, ver. 48. and although this be [...]ot exprefly set down, Gen. 17. in Abrahams family; yet I doubt not, but that as one Scripture gives light unto another, so, this Scripture in Exo. shews the mind of God in the first beginning of the Church, as well as in these times: if therefore the servants who were godly in the family, were only to be circumcised, and their children born in the house with them, then this example is no way leading to corrupt Churches, as you fear it will; but rather the contrary, that if [...] servants then, were received into the Church together with their seed, much more are they received now: And if they did not defile the church then, neither should we think that they will do so now. And I beseech you consider of it, that God [...]as then as carefull of keeping his Church holy as in these dayes, especially in the first constitution of it, as in this of Abrahams Gen. [...]7. And hence God was as much provoked by their unholiness then, as by any unholiness now, 1 Pet. 1 16. Suppose therefore (as you imagine) that all the houshold, whether prophane or holy, were to be received into the Covenant, and so to the seal of it, do you think that this course of admitting all prophane persons then, would not make the Lord soon weary of, and angry with those family-churches, as well as of national, or congregational now, upon the like suppo­sition? if therefore any servants born in the house, or hired, were ad­mitted, surely they were not such unholy ones, whom the Lord could not but be as much angry with, then as now; but they were godly and holy, at least in outward profession, upon which ground the Lord commanded them to be Circumcised.

I know there are some and very holy & learned also, who think that if any godly man undertakes to be as a father to an adopted Pagan or In­dian, that such an one, not grown up to yeares, is from the example in Gen. 17. to be received into the Covenant of the Church, and the seale of it: and I confess, I yet see no convicting argument against it, if it could be proved that some servants bought with Abraham's money were such, and were under years, but I see as yet no convict­ing argument for this assertion from this example; and therefore [Page 13] I stick to the former answer, and see no reason, from any rule of charity, but to believe that all those in Abrahams family, were either visibly godly or the children of such; to whom Circumcision be­long's: and consequently might as well partake of Church-member­ship, as Abraham himself; which sort of servants in these dayes may as well be admitted to Church-membership, without fear of defiling the Church, as their masters themselves.

Object: 2. If Children (say you) be members, then all Children, good and bad, must be received, as Jacob and Esau &c:

Answ. Why not? for if there be any strength in this Argument, it holds as strongly against the admission of professing visible believ­ers: where, though all are externally, and federally holy, yet some, yea many, yea the greatest part of such may be inwardly bad, and as prophane in their hearts, as Esau: and must we therefore refuse them to be Church-members because many of them may be inward­ly bad? verily there must then never be Churches of God in this world. So 'tis among children, they are all outwardly holy, yet many of them may be inwardly unholy, like Esau, must we not therfore accept them to Membership? It is a miserable mistake to think that inward reall holyness is the only ground of admission in­to Church-Membership, as some Anabaptists dispute, but it is fede­ral holyness, whether externally professed as in grown persons, or gra­ciously promised unto their seed.

Reply 1. But you here Reply, If so, then they are of the Church when they are grown up, and prophane, untill they are cast out: and to take in prophane, is sinfull, Ezek. 44.

Answ. It is very true; For 'tis herein just as 'tis in admitting profes­sing believers, they may prove prophane, and continue so in Church­membership, untill they are cast out; but is this therefore any ground to keep out those who are personally holy by their own profession? no verily, why then should such as are parentally, and federally holy be kept out from Church-Membership because they may prove pro­phone me, and being prophane must [...] Church-Members till they be cast out.

Reply 2 But then (you say) they must be Church-Members though their Parents themselves, and the whole Church be unwilling thereunto, [Page 14] even as (say you) a man that marrieth a woman, her children must be his, and he be a Father to them, though he and she, and they should say be shall not be a father in law to them.

Answ. This similitude of marriage doth neither prove, nor illust­rate the thing; For the relation between father and such children is absolute & natural, and hence continues though they say he shall not be their father, and though he profess he will not; but the relation founded upon Church-covenant, between member and member, is not natural, nor only, and allway absolute; but also con­ditionall, which condition not being kept, the relation may be, and is usually broken; for look as the Jews were not so absolutely God's people, but if they did in time reject the Gospel, they were to be cast off, and indeed are so at this day, Rom. 2. 25. Hosea 2. 2. Acts 13 46; 51. So 'tis with all Gentile Churches, and the members thereof:& as for that which you last say, That they may refuse their Parents Co­venant at age, as well as own it, and so may members go out at pleasure, which is disorder. I answer, That the like may be said of such members as come in by personal profession, for they may renounce their own Covenant with God and the Church, one may doe so, and so may twentie, yet though this be wickedness and disorder, yet the Church may proceed against them, and so it may against their Chil­dren, who are bound to own the Covenant made with God, and of God with them in their Parents, as well as any Church-Members are to own their own Covenant by their own personal profession. What disorder therfore will come in as you conceive this way will come in by your own way, and what course you should take to heal the one, by the same you may heal the other.

Object. 3. If Children (say you) be members; then their seed suc­cessively, untill they be either dissolved, or excommunicated; and if so, then what Churches shall we have?

Answ. 1. What Churches shall we have? Truely not allway Churches of Angels and saints, but mixt with many chaffy hypocrites and oft times prophane persons. But still I say this objection holds as firm against gathering Churches of visible professing believers; For God knowe's what Churches we may have of them, even heaps of hypocrites, and prophane persons, for I know not what can give [Page 15] us hope of their not apostatizing, but only Gods promise to be a God to them, and to preserve them; and truly the same promise, be­ing made to their seed, gives me as much ground of faith to hope well of Churches rising out of the seed of the godly, as of the professing Parents themselves. I know one may have more experimental chari­ty concerning some few professing the fear of God, but my Church­charity is equal about them, especially considering, that those whom God receiv's into Church Covenant, he doth not only take them to be a people to him, but to establish them to be such, viz: for time to come. And hence God is said, to establish his Covenant with Isaac, not Ishmael who was to be rejected, Ge [...]. 17. 19. and God is said, to gather them into Covenāt to establish them to be a people, both young & old, present posterity, and that which was to come, Deut. 29. 11,—15.

2 God was as Holy, and as exactly requiring holiness from the Jewish Church, as well as from Christian Churches; now do you think that the Covenant which then wrapt up the Jews children into Church-membership, was an high-way of prophaness, and unholy­ness in the members thereof, & of defiling & polluting Gods Church? or was it a way and meanes of holiness, and to keep them from being prophane? to affirm the first is somthing Blasphemous, and [...]very false, for 'tis expressly said [...]: 13. 11. that as the girdle cleaveth to the loynes of a man, so he [...] the whole house of Israel (not grown men on­ly) to cleave to him, that they might be to him a people (which was by Covenant) and for a name, for a praise, and for a glory; Gods name, Glory, praise was the end; and the Covenant was the meanes hereun­to; and therefore it was no way or meanes of unholyness in that Church: but if you say, it was a meanes of holiness; why then should we f [...]ar the p [...]lluting of Churches by the same Covenant, which we have proved, wraps in our s [...]ed also? indeed they did prove universally prophane in the Jewish Church; so they may in ours, but shall man's wickedness in abuseing God's grace, and for­saking his Covenant tyet [...]e hands, or heart of God's free grace from taking such into Covenant; what though some aid not Believe? saith the Apostle, Rom. 3. 3, 4. s [...]all their unbelief make the Faith of God without effect? God forbid.

3. Suppose they do prove prophane, and corrupt Churches; yet [Page 16] even then, when they are corrupt, they are such Churches, where ordinarily God gathers out his Elect, and out of which (till purer are gathered, or these wholly rejected) there cannot be expected ordi­narily any salvation: for so saith our Saviour, salvation is of the Jews, [...]o [...]: 4. 22. even in that very corrupt, and worst estate of the Church that ever it was in.

Object. 4. If children be members, then they must come to the Lords Supper, for you know no difference between member and member, in point of priviledge, unless they be under some sin.

Answ. 1. Yes verily, there is a plain difference between member and member (though professing believers) in point of priviledge, though they lie under no sin: for, a man may speak and prophesy in the Church, not Women. A company of Men may make a Church, and so receive in, and cast out of the Church, but not Wo­man though professing Saints.

2. All grown men are not to be admitted (though professing Believers) to the Lords Supper; my reason is; A man may Believe in Christ, and yet be very ignorant of the nature, use, and ends of the Lords Supper, now such may be Baptized as soon as ever faith appeares, Mark 16. 16. but they may not be admitted to the Lords Supper, because they will be guilty of the body and blo [...]d of the Lord, if they through their ignorance, cannot discern the Lords body. I know no reason but ignorant persons may be as well suspended from the use of this priviledge, though they be true believers (for faith may consist with much ignorance) as well as distracted persons, who not­withstanding may be believers also.

3. If therefore children be able to examine themselves and discern the Lords body, they may then eat; and herein there is no difference in this priviledge between member and member.

4. Children not being usually able to examine themselves, nor discern the Lords body, hence they are not to be admitted to the use of this pri­viledge: and yet they may be such members as may enjoy the benefit of other priviledges even that of Baptisme: for baptisme seales up our first entrance into the Covenant. This first entrance is not allway by personal profession of Faith, but by Gods promise of working, or of vouchsafeing the meanes of working of it, now Children (as is [Page 17] proved) being under this Covenant (as we see all the posterity also of Abraham was) hence though children cannot profess faith, nor actu­ally examine themselves yet they may receive, and must receive bap­tisme, being allready under Gods Covenant; but because the Lords Supper doth not seal up this first entrance, and first right to the Co­venant, but our growth and fruition of the Covenant; hence this act on our part is required to participate in this, which the Apostle calls self-examination, and the act of takeing, and [...] Christ, and of [...]iscerning the Lords [...]ody), and of doing this in remembrance of Christ: which every baptised person, and Church-member is not allway able to do. A child may receive a promise aforehand of a rich estate given him, and this promise sealed up to him, his father receiving it for him, but it is not fit that he should be put to the actual improve­ment, and fruition of that estate, untill he is grown up, understands himselfe, and knows how to do it: so 'tis here, the Sacrament of the Lords Supper requires ability, 1. To take Christ as our own. 2. To eat Christ, that is, to take fruition of him: the which acts of faith, God doth not require of all those immediately, who are wrapt up in Covenant with him.

Object. 1. But here you say, that that examination 1 Cor 11. is required of all that be members, and that at all times▪, as well as at their first comming to the Lords Supper.

Answ. This examination is indeed required of all those members who should partake of the Lords Supper, but it is not required (as you seem to say) of every one to make him a member, so that none can be a member, but him that is able to examine himselfe; for Gods Co­venant to work faith, and to give power to examine one's selfe after­ward, may make some as truely members as those who are able to act & express their faith. Now I have proved that Gods Covenant is aforehand given to children: and to give them the seal of their first entrance into it many yeares after, is as vile a thing, as for them that are able, and fit to examine themselves, to have this Sacrament of the Lord, Supper denied, or delaied till many yeares after.

Object. 2. But you say, It's left to every ones conscience to exa­mine himself, not that others should examine them, and consequently if▪ children be members, then it must be left upon their conscience.

[Page 18] Answ. We know in our own consciences that Children usually cannot examine themselves, now if the Elders & the Church are boūd to see Christs rules observed by others, and if this examination be the rule that all must walk by who participate here, then they must not suffer such yong ones, no nor persons grown up, and entred [...]n by personal profession, to receive this seal, as they know are unable thus to do: I think if Churches should degenerate in these dayes, this course of Discipline should be attended (especially by the Elders) to­ward [...]y of their members, which way soever they have entred, whether by their own, or by their parents covenant: And I have oft feared that there is some need already of it, even toward some who en­ter by their own covenant, and may have saith, but are miserably to seek in the nature, use, and ends of the Lords Supper, and consequently unfit to discern of Christ's body, and so to come to that Sacrament.

Object. 5. If Children may be members, & yet not come to the Lords Supper; then it may come to pass that a whole Church may be a Church, and yet not have the Lords Supper, or ought not to have it.

Answ. 1. So there may, for a Church may be a true Church,& yet want the benefit of some one or more of Gods Ordinances, sometime Pastors, sometime Elders, sometime Seales.

2. A Church of professing Believers may degenerate, and turn prophane, and sottish, and to have no just right to the Seales; and their Officers may leave them, and so have no use of the Seales: yet I suppose it is a Church of Christ still though degenerate, though unfit to enjoy Seales; will you therfore think one way of [...] Membership unlawfull, viz. by professing their Faith? Because such a rare thing as this may happen? why then should you think the way of [...] Membership unlawfull because of the like rarity in such a d [...]k and gloomy state of them as you mention?

Object. 6. If Children be Members, then [...] will be many in the Church, who are not Saints by calling, [...] in Christ Jesus, which ought not to be [...] Church could [...] so may [...] plain­ly seen.

Answ. 1. I do think it's true, that poor Children may be and are [...] upon with [...], any [...] bought [...]f unbelief, [...] of them as Children of wrath by [...], and not with such high [Page 19] thought [...] of Faith, as Children, and Sons of God by promise, as I have shewn. And I think herein is out great sin, as it was in Christ's own disciples, who were the first▪ that we read of that would not have lit­tle Children brought unto him, for which he rebuked them, shewing their priviledge; and for want of which faith in Gods promise about our children, certainly God smites, and forsakes many of our children.

2. If therefore you think that Church-members must consist on­ly of saints by calling; so that your meaning is, such saints as are so by outward and personal profession, from the call of the Gospel, are only to be Church-members; this is an errour: For, 1. You know that they who define a Church to be a number of visible saints, they usually put this phrase in, [ and their seen] who may not profess faith perhaps as their Fathers do: and you shall find that the Israel of God under the old Testament, are all of them said to be adopted, Rom. 9. 4. chosen and called, Isa [...] 41. 8, 9. and faithfull, Isai. 1. 21. and yet we know they were not all so by personal profession, but in respect of their joynt federation, and the outward Covenant of God with them. 2. The outward Covenant is not allway first entred into by personal profession of faith, but by Gods Covenant of promise to work, or to use the meanes to work faith: Hence it undeniably follows; that as many may be in Church-covenant before they profess faith personally, so many may be members of the Church without this profession of faith; for this Covenant of working faith (as hath been formerly explained) doth not only belong to the Jews, but to Gentile Churches also, and Believers; as hath been proved, and might further be confirmed.

Object: But say you, If we saw hypocrites, we were to cast them out as well as prophane persons: and we see no grace in many children, and therefore they must not be received in.

Answ. 1. If you see children, of whom you cannot say that they are faithfull personally, yet they may be faithfull federally (as hath been shewed) for they may lie under God [...] Covenant of begetting faith, by some meanes in them; and then you are not to cast them out, but accept them, as God doth.

3. The children of godly parents though they do not manifest faith in the Gospel, yet they are to be accounted of Gods Church [...], [Page 20] untill they positively reject the Gospel, either in themselves, or in their Parents; and therefore God did never goe about to cast off he Jews, and their seed, untill they put forth positive unb [...]l [...]e [...]; the Lord promised to give them the means of Faith, and did so: and when Christ was come, and the Gospel sent first unto them for their good, the Lord herein fullfill'd his Covenant-Mercy, as toward his Beloved people; but when they rejected these meanes, and cast off Christ, and his Gospel, then Rom. 11. they were broken off, and not before. Now hypocrites are such as profess Christ in words, and yet deny Christ in deed,▪ Titus 1. 16. 2 Tim. 3. 5. Hence they are such, as positively re­fuse Christ: hence the case of children in whom no positive unbeliefe appeares, is not the same with this of hypocrites, or prophane per­sons; and when young Children shall grow positively such, I know not but they may be dealt with as any other Members, for any such like offence.

Thus you see an answer to your Six Objections. In the end of your paper there are TWO QUESTIONS, which I suppose may not a little trouble against their Baptisme and membership. To these briefly.

Quest. 1. What good (say you) is it, either for a wicked, or an elect Child, till he be converted, to be in the Church? or what good may any have by being in the Church, till they can profit by what they enjoy?

Answ. 1 The Apostle put's the like case, and gives you an Answer Rom. 3. 1, 2. what advantage hath the Jew, and what profit is there of Cir­cumcision? what use or profit could the Infants then make of their Church-Covenant, Membership, or Seal, who understood none of these things? do you think the Lord exposed his holy ordinances then unto contempt? and is more carefull that they may be profitably used now? was there no good by Circumcision? yea saith the Apostle, much every way.

2. What profit is it to persons grown up to yeares, and yet secretly hy­pocrites, who enter into the Church by profession of the faith? you will say there is good and profit in respect of the priviledges themselves, but they abusing them they had, in this respect, better have been without them, because they bring hereby upon themselves greater condemna­tion. The same say I of children, whom God receives into his [Page 21] Church, by promise, and Covenant of doing them good, although at present they may not be so sensible of this good.

3. To speak plainly, the good they get by being thus enriched is won­derfull: and here there is more need of a Treat [...]s [...] then of a Letter, to clear up the benefits from all Scruples, arising by being in outward Covenant, in Church fellowship, even unto Infants: I confess I find little said by Writers upon this Subject, & I believe the doubts against childrens Baptisme, as they arise by blindness in this particular; so I think that God suffers that opinion to take place, that by such dark­ness he may bring out light in this particular. I will only hint unto you some few of my many thoughts, which have long exercised me for many yeares in this thing. The good by childrens membership, especially when Sealed, is in four things.

1. In respect of God. God shews hereby the riches of his grace to­ward them, in taking them to be his people: In Adopting them to be his children: In preventing them with many special promises aforehand of doing them good; by all which, the Lord doth as it were prevent Sa­tan, in wooing their hearts as it were, so soon to draw them to him before he can actually [...] to draw their soules from him. So that I beseech you consider, suppose they cannot as yet understand, and so make profit by all this, yet is it not good for them, or for any of us to partake of Gods grace, before we know how to make use of it? is it not good for God to be good to them that are evil? is it not good for God to glorifie & make manifest his grace to man, though man knowes not how to make use of his grace? was it not rich grace for Christ to wash Peters feet, and yet he not know at present what it meant, only (saith Christ) thou shalt know it afterward? is it not good for God to give life to us, and to let us be born in such and such a place of the Gospel where it is preached, and to lay in mercy aforehand for us, before we know how to be thankfull, or know how to use any of these outward mercies? and is it no mercy or favour to have so much spiritual mercy bestowed on children a­forehand, before they can be thankfull, or make use thereof? Deut. 7. 6, 7. The choosing of them to be his people, above all other people (which you know was from the womb) it's called Gods [...] his Love upon them, and the reason of this Love, verse 8. is said to be, [Page 22] because God loved them, this love was not Electing, & peculiar love, (for thousands of these perished and went to hell) but it was his ex­ternall adopting love to choose them to be his people, and to improve all means for their good, and to give them the good of all those means unless they refuse: and to give indefinitely among them, and particu­larly to many of them, such hearts as that they shall not be able to refuse the good of those meanes (as hath been shewed formerly) this is love, great love & mercy; not shewn or promised to any who are not of the visible Church throughout the whole world. By which God is glorified; & let him be so, though we cannot see how to pro­fit by it, when it first break's out; Have not you profited much by considering Gods preventing grace, long before you understood how to make use of it? hath not God received much glory from you for it? hath this grace then think you, been unprofitably spent on Gods part? No verily: The case is the same here, David blesseth God; for bring his God from his Mothers belly, and from the womb, Psal. 22. 9, 10. and Gods grace is shewn through this expression, Isai. 46. 3.

2. The [...]e is much good hereby in respect of the Parents; for, suppose the children cannot profit by it, yet Parents may, and 'tis in respect of them very much that God looks upon their children, thus to receive them into Covenant, Deut. 4. 37. For, 1. Parents may hereby see, and wonder at the riches of Gods grace, to become a God▪ not only to themselves, but to take in their seed also, whose good they prize as their own, and as if done to themselves: hence Abra­ham fell down upon his face, adoring God, when he heard of this Co­venant, Gen. 17. See also how Moses aggravates this love, in the eyes of all that had eyes to see, Deut. 10. 14, 15. 2. Hereby God gives Pa­rents some comfortable hope of their childrens salvation; because they be within the pale of the visible Church; for as out of the visible Church (where the ordinary meanes of salvation be) there is ordinarily no salvation, Acts 2. 47. So if children were not of Christs visible Church and Kingdome, we could not hope for their salvation, no more then of Pagans, or Turks; for if they be without God, they are without hope, Ephes. 2. 12. and to be without hope of such, to whom God hath made such promises of salvation, not given to Pa­gans, nor proper to Abraham, is very hard, and horrid to imagine; [Page 23] for the promise run's universally, that the Seed of the upright (whe­ther Jews, or Gentiles) shall be Blessed. Psal. 112. 1, 2. Prov. 20. 7. 3. Hereby Parents are stirred up the more earnestly to Pray for them, because God's Covenant and promise is so large toward them, at which Prayer look's, and by which it wrestle's with God, and hence, we find that Moses, and others, they use this argument in their Prayers; oh God of Abraham, Isaac, and Iacob: &c: 4. Hereby they may not only hope, and Pray, but are incouraged to Believe, con­cerning their Children and the rest of those who are in Covenant a­mong them, that God will do them good, as they conclude mercy to the remnant, forgivness of their sins, with faith, upon this ground, thou wilt remember the Truth to Jacob, and thy Mercy to Abraham [...], sworn unto our Fathers in dayes of old, Micah 7. 18, 20. This indeed is the childrens faith for themselves, and their children: but so it may be a ground of Parents faith: And if we pray for our children, why should we doubt (leaving only secrets to God) if we see them dy before they reject the Gospel positively; I see no reason for any man to doubt of the salvation of his child if he dyes, or that God will not do good to his child in time if he lives. 5. This stirrs up their hearts to be the more sincerely holy, and keep in with God, because of their children; and to educate them with more care, and watchfullness, be­cause they are the Lord's Children as well as theirs; they are not common, but holy vessells, and therfore let them see that they be not defiled; and hence we find, that when God exhort's to any duty of holiness in Scripture he oft makes this the ground of it [ I am your God] and hence God aggravates their sin in offering their children to Molech, Ezek. 16. because they were his children, that should have been better used.

3. In respect of themselves, the good is very great. 1. It is a spe­cial meanes to prevent sin, Deut. 29. I make this Covenant, not only with him that is present, but with your seed also, who are not here, verse 15. Lest there should be among you man, or woman, family, or tribe, whose heart turnes away from God, and lest there should be a root of gall and wormwood: and indeed it mightily workes on the heart to think; shall I whom God hath chosen▪ to be his, be my own; or be the Divels, or be my lusts&c? 2. 'Tis a strong motive & en­gagement [Page 24] upon them to forsake sin, even the uncircumcision and sin of their hearts, as is evident, Deut. 10. 15, 16. The Lord had a delight to choose the seed of your fathers, even you to be his people, as it is this day: what follow's? Therefore Circumcise the foreskin of your hearts, and be [...] more stiff-necked: 3. 'Tis a special help, as to avert their hearts from sin, so to convert & turn them to God,& to make them look toward God, that he would turn them, when perhaps they are with­out any hope (in other respects) of mercy, or of being able by any meanes they can use to turn themselves; this is evident, Acts 3. 19. with verse 25. Repent and be converted, for you are the children of the Covenant, which God made with our fathers; this drawes their hearts, when they see, how God call's them to return, Jer. 3. 22. Come un­to me ye back sliding children &c: we come unto thee, for thou art the Lord our God, When backsliding Ephraim could not convert him­selfe, he cryes unto God, oh turn me, and I shall be turned, for thou art the Lord my God, Jer. 31. 18. which places cannot be meant [...] being their God only by internal Covenant, in giving to them the spe­cial benefits of the Covenant, for then they should be in Covenant with God▪ and have remission of all their sins, &c. before they were turned, or before faith? and therefore it's meant of being a God in out­ward, and external church-Covenant, which is no smal motive, and loadstone to Believe. And although many do not believe, and will not be turned, yet this Covenant is an high priviledge, and great fa­vour, fitt in it self, to draw to God, though many believe not▪ and hence the Apostle saith, that the priviledge of the Jew is great, in having God's Oracles (which contain God's Covenant) committed to them, though some believe not, which unbelief make's not (he saith) the faith of God, i. e. God's promise or Covenant of none effect, or an uneffectual, and fruitless Covenant: for this word of God's Covenant shall take some effect among some such as are in it; which therfore is a priviledge, though many perish, as is evident, Rom. 9. 4, 6. 4. 'Tis a special meanes of binding them fast to God, when they are turned: Ier. 13. 11. as the girdle [...] unto a man, so have I caus­ed the whole house of Israel; to cleave unto me, that they may be for a name, and glory, Deut. 30. 20. thou shalt cleave unto him, because he is thy life, and the length of thy dayes: he was not their life spiritually, [Page 25] and savingly, (for many thus exhorted, [...] dead, and in their sins) but federally, or in outward Covenant. 5. If they shall forsake, and break loose from God, and from t [...]e bond of his Covenant, and have (as much as in them lies) cast themselves out of Covenant, by their own perfidious­ness, & breach of Covenant, that one would think now there is no more hope; yet it is a special meanes, to encourage their hearts to return again: even when they seem to be utterly cast off, and therefore it's said Jer. 3 1. though thou hast committed whoredome with many [...]overs (wherby the co­venant was broken) yet return unto me: so Deut. 4. If when you are scat­tered among the nations, and shall serve wood & stone, and be in great tribu­lation, if from thence thou seek the Lord thy God, thou shalt find him, he wi [...] not forsake thee; and what is the reason of it? viz. his remem­brance of the Covenant with their fathers, for so 'tis Deut. 4. 27, 28, 29, 30 31. But I forbear to name more such things as these which come by outward Covenant to Inchurched Members.

4. [...] respect of others their good is very great; for, 1. now they may enjoy t [...]e special watch and care of the whole Church, which otherwise they must want. 2. They hereby have the more fervent Prayers of others for then [...]: and hence Rom. 9. 1, 2, 3. we see how Paul upon this ground had great zeal in his prayers for the Jews, not only because his country­men, but especially because to them did belong the Adoption, and Cove­nants, & they had gracious Fathers &c. so Psal. 89. 49. Lord remember thy former loving kindnesses, which are sworn to David in truth. And hence we see Moses oft pleads and prevailes with God in prayer, for the sinning Israelites, viz. oh Remember Abraham, Isaac, and Iacob.

Now I pray you, lay all these things together, and then see whether you have any cause to say; What profit is there by Covenant and Church-membership of persons not yet able to profess the faith of Jesus Christ?

Quest. 2. You say▪ when families were Churches, all of the family were of he Church, and when a Nation was a Church, all that were of that na­tion were of that Church; But now Believers being matter of the Church, what of [...] were admitted, till they can hold forth visible faith, would not many of [...] things be more clear?

Answ. In these words there is a threefold mistake.

That all of the family & nation in former times, were of the Church: [Page 26] this is false, for God never took any [...] his Church, but as they were Believers, at le [...] [...], in that Nation; I say Believers: which either are practised believers: or pro­ [...]ised believers; such as by outward Covenant shall have the meanes to be made believers in [...]; and hence you have heard, that the Nation of the Jews [...] by Faith, and were broken [...] by unbeliefe, and if any rejected the Covenant: as [...] and [...], they were [...] of that Church, though they did, and might dwell in [...] nation, as [...].

2. You think that Visible personal Faith only, makes the Church, and members or it; which [...]in errour, as may appear from many things already [...]: for Children may be in Gods ac­count professors or [...] Faith parentally, as well as personally [...] the profession of their par­ents, as well as in their own; And sence you shall had, that the Covenant God entered into with the Parents of Church-members personally, the Children are said, to have that Covenant [...] with them many hundred years after; See for this purpose, among hundreds, their [...]. Scriptures, [...] 2. 5. In Hagg [...]i time God is [...]id to make a Covenant with them th [...] then they came [...] of Egypt (which was a [...]t personally, but parentally) so Ha [...]es 12. 4, 5. when [...]od entred into Covenant with Jacob at Bethel; God is said to speak [...], who lived many yeares after; and [...]ence the Children many yeares [...], challenge Gods Covenant with them, which was made with their Fathers for them, [...] 7. 19, 20. Hence also [...] Children are said to co [...] to Christ (who were not able to [...]) but only were brought in the armes of others to Christ. It's [...] thing among [...], that a Father [...]ay receive a gift, or Legacy given to him, and his heires, and he, and his heires are bound [...] perform the condition of the Covenant, and promise by which it is conveyed, and that the Child doth this in his Father.

3. You think that if men only, grown up, and able to profess, Faith, should be, if the Church, then all things would [...] more clear [...] Children: Truly I belie [...]e [...] ground, before [...]aid downing [...], 1. Hereby pollution of [...] Church [...] avoyded, but rather introduced, to exclude [...] from an [...] holy▪ making. Covenant, [...]s we have proved. 2. Hereby that rood and benefit of their Covenant, should be [...] not gai [...]d) by excluding them out of Covenant, untill they can personally [...] of the Covenant: The wisdome of man furthers not the Rightousness [...] me conclude with the naked profession of my Faith to you in this [...] of defence against all that is said by Anabaptist against baptisme of [...].

1. That the Children of professing Believers are in the same Covenant God made with Abraham; Abraham was a Father of many nations, and not of one nation only, and hence the same Covenant made with hear, and the believ­ing Israel in that nation, the [...] Covenant is made with all his behaving seed [...] all other nations. 2. That Baptism [...] is a seal of our first entrance, and admission into Covenant: and therfore is to be immediately applyed to children of believeing parent, a [...] soon as ever they be in Covenant, and that is a [...] soon as they become the visible seed of the faithfull for [...] Covenant to Abra­ham r [...]n's (I will be thy God, and the God of thy seed) not only [...] & seed, but Church-seed, (as hath been shew'd) not only of his seed in that [...] nation, but in all Nations.

Th [...]se two things I cannot tell how to avoid [...] of, the [...] [...] clear: and the igno­rance of these make [...] as they are called [...] yet met wit [...] [...] thing written by [...] any considerable w [...]ight [...] throw the [...]e. But I [...] My prayer is and [...], That [...] Lord [...].

FINIS.

Preface, [...] L [...]ne 20. read wonted [...] have fought. p. 7. [...] 28. r. spirit [...], [...] 29. [...]. In [...] page. [...] for now [...].

This keyboarded and encoded edition of the work described above is co-owned by the institutions providing financial support to the Text Creation Partnership. This Phase I text is available for reuse, according to the terms of Creative Commons 0 1.0 Universal. The text can be copied, modified, distributed and performed, even for commercial purposes, all without asking permission.